Headnotes - Oct 15 2018

Announcements

Deans' Offices

Yak’s Snacks, Weds, Oct 17

Please join Dean Ed Iacobucci at “Yak’s Snacks”.
Location: Jackman Atrium
Time:  10 – 11 a.m.
Please BRING YOUR OWN MUG

Nominations for 2019 Ann Wilson and Robert Prichard Award for Community and Professional Service (Deadline Oct. 24)

The Ann Wilson and Robert Prichard for Community and Professional Service Award honours a recent graduate of the Faculty of Law (5-15 years since graduation) who demonstrates the highest standards of professional integrity, excellence and leadership, and who has made a significant contribution to the legal profession and/or community through their public interest work, pro bono activities and/or community service.  The recipient will be selected by the Law Alumni Association Council Nominations Sub-Committee and the award will be presented bi-annually at the Distinguished Alumni Award ceremony.

The 2019 Distinguished Alumni Award ceremony will be held in Spring 2019. It is expected that the Wilson Prichard Award recipient is available to accept their award in person; the date for the ceremony will be announced in late Fall 2018.

Nominate Here

Discussion with Justices Ian Binnie and Robert Armstrong

The Honourable Justice Robert Armstrong (formerly of the Court of Appeal for Ontario) offers a course that examines the role of the judge in our judicial system with particular reference to the notion of judicial activism. On Thursday, October 25, 2018 that class will include a visit from the Honourable Ian Binnie (formerly of the Supreme Court of Canada).  Justice Armstrong is opening the class to the entire law school community. Please join them from 12:30 to 2:00 pm in Room P120. RSVP required by the end of the day on Friday, October 19th.

Lawyers Doing Cool Things - Zimra Yetnikoff J.D. 2006

Lawyers Doing Cool Things Lunch - Zimra Yetnikoff J.D. 2006

Wednesday October 17, 2018, 12:30 – 1:30
Room J225 (John Willis classroom)

Sandwiches and water will be provided.

Zimra Yitnikoff, J.D. 2006Career profile:  Zimra is Director of Investigations & Hearings at the College of Psychologists of Ontario, where she oversees complaint, discipline, remediation and fitness to practice matters regarding registered psychologists and psychological associates. Prior to becoming Director she was a Case Manager at the College, and was responsible for investigating allegations of professional misconduct.

https://www.linkedin.com/in/zimra-yetnikoff-a1587623/

Registration is limited to 20 students. Please click here

Getting Better at Talking to Everyone - Leadership Skills Workshop

Leadership Skills Workshop - Getting Better at Talking to Everyone

Tuesday October 17th, 12:30 – 2:00, location J125

Workshop description: You have great ideas and are excited to share them with peers, colleagues, and professors. You’ve worked hard, prepared, and did your best to share your vision—still, people didn’t understand.

In this workshop, you’ll learn how to talk about your ideas using language that makes sense to other people. Specifically, you’ll learn simple tools for doing three things better:

  • Thinking about the audience for your ideas (what are they looking for)
  • Getting that audience to listen (compelling stories stand out)
  • Helping that audience understand

This workshop is a great opportunity for all students, especially those who are anxious public speakers, and/or those who are heading into job interviews soon. 

To register, click here

Chris Graham

Chris Graham has been a professional for over a decade. He’s twice been a lawyer: at Sullivan & Cromwell LLP in New York, representing very large banks; and at Pape Salter Teillet LLP in Toronto, representing Aboriginal governments across Canada. (You’d be surprised by the overlap in these two practices. Just ask.)  He is a graduate of the Faculty of Law (J.D. 2006).

Chris is the producer of AMAZING NEW STUFF, a performance series featuring outrageous literary and musical talents in small venues. He’s also an investor in Artery, a platform for making every space a stage.

His writing has appeared in publications in Canada and the USA; he edits a legal encyclopedia; and he regularly tells stories on stages. (He's currently working on a one-person storytelling show called A Child Pets a Kitten with a Hammer, about emotional resiliency in terminal cancer care situations.)

He holds degrees from the University of Oxford (history and politics), University of Toronto (law), and Acadia University (business).

Chris is the founder of TellPeople (www.tellpeople.ca), a vehicle for teaching empathy-based storytelling to professionals.

Student Office

Academic Support Services at the Law School

Academic Support Program: The ASP connects 1L students with upper-year Academic Advisors who provide one-on-one and small group assistance to those who would like academic support. Our upper year Academic Advisors are Dean’s list students who are keen to provide course-specific advice about summarizing cases, preparing for class, studying for exams, and writing papers. Many of our Academic Advisors used the ASP when they were 1Ls.

The ASP is a free and confidential service. You can access the program as individuals or in small study groups. Please email academic.support@utoronto.ca to book appointments. You will be asked to specify when you are available and which course(s) you would like to focus on.

Learning Strategist:  JD students can book appointments with a Learning Strategist from the University’s Academic Success Centre. Learning Strategists help students tackle challenges associated with heavy reading loads, the lure of procrastination, deadline crunches, and challenges associated with transitioning to a new discipline. To book an appointment please email: kathleen.ogden@utoronto.ca

Writing coaching:  JD students can meet one-on-one with an academic writing instructor who will assist students with specific assignments as well as general writing skills. During a 30-45 minute session, a Professor will read a work-in-progress and offer feedback on organization, documentation, grammar, structure, and punctuation. To book an appointment, please email: jbarbara rose jbarbararose@sympatico.ca

For more details about our academic support services, please go to http://www.law.utoronto.ca/student-life/academic-support

Mindfulness Program: Drop-In Guided Meditation

Take a break and join us for a "Mindful Monday" drop-in guided meditation session.

On October 15th from 1:00pm to 1:30pm, Yukimi Henry will be facilitating a guided mindfulness meditation session in the Quiet Room at the law school (in the basement, near the lockers).

This event is open to all law school community members - students, staff and faculty. A few meditation cushions and yoga mats are available for use, but feel free to bring your own.

No registration is required. We ask that you be arrive just before 1:00pm to avoid disrupting the session once we have begun. For more information email yukimi.henry@utoronto.ca.

MIndfulness Program: "Letting Go of Perfectionism"

U of T MIndfulness Program welcomes back expert facilitator Elli Weisbaum to lead another mindfulness session. Learn about the neuroscience and engage in guided mindfulness practices on the topic of "Letting Go of Perfectionism".

Everyone from the law school community is welcome - students, staff & faculty!

Monday, October 29th
12:30-1:50pm

John Willis Classroom, FL219

A light lunch will be provided. Space is limited so please register in advance. Registration through this link: https://www.eventbrite.ca/e/uoft-law-mindfulness-program-letting-go-of-p...

For questions please contact Yukimi Henry at yukimi.henry@utoronto.ca.

New embedded Accessibility Advisor - Welcome Reshma Dhrodia

Dear students, staff and faculty

I am writing to let you know about a new initiative with Accessibility Services (AS). Starting this year, the University is embedding 10 additional Accessibility Services advisors at locations throughout the St. George campus. The goal is to make it easier for students to access AS’s services.   

We are excited to welcome Reshma Dhrodia as the On Location Accessibility Advisor for Professional Faculties North. Reshma provides support to OISE, Social Work, and Law students. Her primary office is located in the Factor-Inwentash Faculty of Social Work: 246 Bloor St. West, Rm 438; Phone: 416-978-7759, Fax: 416-978-5729.

Starting Wednesday October 10th, Reshma will also have office hours on Wednesdays at the law school. Her office is located on the 3rd floor of Flavelle House.  

An FAQ is attached describing Reshma’s new role and how she will be available to support our students. Please review this document as it will help to address questions that you may have. You are also welcome to contact Reshma directly should you have questions after reviewing the FAQ: reshma.dhrodia@utoronto.ca.

Here is Reshma’s bio:  Reshma (MA, MSW, RSW) is a social worker and social justice advocate whose professional interests are in equity, anti-oppressive practice, mental health, gender-based violence, and climate change. She is a graduate of the FIFSW. Between 2012 and 2014, she managed a community-university project to engage students to prevent gender-based violence at UTSC. She also worked as a Senior’s Mental Health Consultant with West Park Healthcare Centre between 2012 and 2016. In 2014, she delivered TEDx talk on age discrimination called, "The Trouble with Aging." Reshma has been a board member of the Urban Alliance on Race Relations since 2015. In 2016, she joined the FIFSW as the Student Life, Outreach, and Equity Advisor. She has been a U of T Accessibility Advisor since 2017.

Please join me in welcoming Reshma to the law school.

 

Best regards

Alexis

Academic Events

Goodman Lecture: India's Ban on Gay Sex: “Irrational, indefensible, and manifestly arbitrary”

 

“Irrational, indefensible, and manifestly arbitrary.” 

Professor Menaka Guruswamy, Columbia Law School, recently represented gay petitioners in India’s Supreme Court, successfully arguing that India’s ban against consensual gay sex should be struck down.    In its unanimous decision the justices ruled gay Indians are to be accorded all the protections of the Constitution.  She will discuss the case, discussed in this article, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/06/world/asia/india-gay-sex-377.html, during this year’s Goodman Lecture.  The Lecture will take place on Tuesday, October 23, at 4:10 pm in the Moot Court Room.

State of Religious Freedom in Canada

The Law, Religion and Democracy Lab welcomes Mr. Derek B.M. Ross, LLB, LLM, who will speak on the state of religious freedom in Canada post-TWU decision. 

Mr. Ross is the Executive Director and General Counsel of the Christian Legal Fellowship of Canada. 

Please note that this event is held at the same time and place as the Law and Religion seminar. 

Date: October 25, Thursday

Venue: Solarium (FA2)

Time: 2:10 - 4:00 pm

 

 

Law and Economics Colloquium: Ahmed Taha

LAW & ECONOMICS COLLOQUIUM

presents

Ahmed Taha
Pepperdine University School of Law

Regulating the Advertising of Opinions: An Experimental Investigation
(with John Petrocelli)

Tuesday, October 16, 2018
4:10 - 5:45
Room FL219 (John Willis Classroom)
78 Queen's Park 

Advertisements of many goods and services feature endorsements from consumers who have had atypically positive experiences with them.  Substantial evidence suggests that consumers often erroneously assume that advertised, atypical results are typical.  Thus, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) requires advertisements of atypical results also to disclose the typical results.  However, the FTC has created an exception for advertisements featuring atypically positive opinions regarding a product.  The exception exists because the FTC assumes that consumers believe that advertised opinions only necessarily represent the opinions of the people expressing the opinions.  To test the FTC’s assumption, we conduct a controlled experiment.  We find evidence that, contrary to the FTC’s assumption, consumers believe that an advertised opinion is the typical consumer opinion.  In addition, we find evidence that requiring these advertisements to also disclose the typical consumer opinion would cause consumers to greatly discount advertised atypical opinions. 

Professor Taha's research focuses primarily on consumer and investor protection law. This research reflects both his training in law and in economics in which he holds a Ph.D.  His research has been discussed in national media outlets, including the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal. He is also the Faculty Director of the Palmer Center for Entrepreneurship and the Law.

Prior to joining the Pepperdine faculty, Professor Taha was a professor at Wake Forest Law School, an attorney in the Antitrust Division of the U. S. Department of Justice in Washington, D.C., a litigation associate with Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati in Palo Alto, California, and a corporate finance analyst at McKinsey and Company in New York. Professor Taha teaches Civil Procedure, Corporations, and Accounting and Finance for Lawyers." 

For more workshop information, please send an email to events.law@utoronto.ca

IIO Speakers series presents Brenda Gunn on United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People

 IIO Speakers series presents

Brenda Gunn on United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People

October 22, 12:30 Jackman Law Building P120

 

A discussion on challenges and opportunities to Implement the UN Declaration in Canada, with some specific discussion of women’s rights and Bill 262.

 
Brenda L. Gunn, Associate Professor Robson Hall Faculty of Law. She has a B.A. from the University of Manitoba and a J.D. from the University of Toronto.  She completed her LL.M. in Indigenous Peoples Law & Policy at the University of Arizona. She was called to the bars of Law Society of Upper Canada and Manitoba.  As a proud Metis woman she continues to combine her academic research with her activism pushing for greater recognition of Indigenous peoples’ inherent rights as determined by Indigenous peoples’ own legal traditions. Her current research focuses on promoting greater conformity between international law on the rights of Indigenous peoples and domestic law.  She provided technical assistance to the UN Expert Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples in the analysis and drafting of the report summarizing the responses on the survey on implementing the UN Declaration.   She developed a handbook on understanding and implementing the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples that is quickly becoming one of the main resources in Canada on the UN Declaration (http://www.indigenousbar.ca/pdf/undrip_handbook.pdf) and has delivered workshops on the Declaration across Canada and internationally. 
 
Mary and Philip Seeman Health Law, Policy & Ethics Seminar Series: Alana Klein

MARY AND PHILIP SEEMAN HEALTH LAW, POLICY & ETHICS SEMINAR SERIES 

presents 

Alana Klein, Associate Professor
Faculty of Law, McGill University

The Renewal of the Judicial Function in the Protection of Health:
Visions in Constitutional, Criminal and Private Law
 

Commentator:
Kate Glover Berger, Assistant Professor
Faculty of Law, Western University 

Thursday, October 18, 2018
12:30 - 2:00
Solarium (room FA2), Falconer Hall
84 Queen's Park
 

Canadian courts are playing a growing role in shaping health policy, with a greater tendency to recognize social and political issues related to health as justiciable. This can be attributed both to increasing rights-based challenges to laws that are viewed as threatening citizens’ health, and to an understanding of law as a determinant of health. Courts started to look more closely at the scope, terms and quality of health care delivery, often through constitutional challenges to legislation. There is also growing recognition of the complex links between approaches to criminal justice and mental and physical health problems. In private law, the judicial contribution to health policy is characterized by a new vision of the role of civil responsibility as an ex ante mechanism for the regulation of health risks. Professor Klein will analyze the contribution of modern legal normativity to the achievement of social objectives related to health. She will focus on how the judiciary, in applying constitutional, criminal and private law rules, views its role in the design, implementation, and revision of social policies related to health. 

Alana Klein is an Associate Professor at the Faculty of Law, McGill University, where she is co-convener of the Research Group on Health and Law. She earned her SJD from Columbia Law School in 2011, her BCL and LLB from McGill University, and her BA degree from Concordia University. She teaches and researches in the areas of health law, criminal law and human and constitutional rights. Recent and current projects have focused on matters including harm reduction, criminalization of disease and law's role in governance. 

A light lunch will be provided 

For more information about this workshop, please send an e-mail to events.law@utoronto.ca

Legal Theory Workshop: Mark Walters

LEGAL THEORY WORKSHOP
presents

Mark Walters
McGill University Faculty of Law

A.V. Dicey and the Common Law Constitutional Tradition:
A Legal Turn of Mind

Friday, October 26, 2018
12:30 - 2:00
Solarium (room FA2), Falconer Hall
84 Queen's Park

Note from the author:
In the workshop, I would like to discuss parts of a book that I am working on. It is a quasi-biographical account of the constitutional law scholarship of Albert Venn Dicey. I have given you a draft of the entire book, but of course you will not have time to read it all. I will use chapters 8 and 10 as the basis for a discussion about the relationship between law and sovereignty. The book is very much still in progress, and any thoughts you have about it would be very much appreciated. MW

Mark Walters obtained a B.A. (Political Science) from the University of Western Ontario in 1986, a LL.B. from Queen’s University in 1989, and a D.Phil. from Oxford University in 1996. After practicing law briefly, he returned to Oxford to teach for several years and then joined the Faculty of Law at Queen’s in 1999. He became a Full Professor at Queen’s in 2008 and served as Associate Dean (Graduate Studies and Research) between 2008 and 2010.  Professor Walters researches and publishes in the areas of public and constitutional law, legal history, and legal theory, with a special emphasis on the rights of indigenous peoples, institutional structures, and the history of legal ideas. 

He has held a number of fellowships, including the Jules and Gabrielle Léger Fellowship (SSHRC), the Sir Neil MacCormick Fellowship (University of Edinburgh), the Herbert Smith Fellowship (Cambridge University) and the H.L.A. Hart Fellowship (Oxford University).  He was appointed F.R. Scott Professor of Public and Constitutional Law at McGill University on July 1, 2016.

 
To be added to the paper distribution list, please send an email to events.law@utoronto.ca.  For further information, please contact Professor Larissa Katz (larissa.katz@utoronto.ca) and Professor Sophia Moreau (sr.moreau@utoronto.ca).

2019 Fall Mergers and Acquisitions Roundtable at the Faculty of Law

The Faculty of Law will be holding its 2018 Fall Roundtable on Mergers and Acquisitions on Friday, November 2, 2018 at 8:30 am in the Moot Court Room.
 
Over the past year, Canadian capital markets have witnessed a surge in M&A activity. This activity is particularly conspicuous in the energy and power sectors as well as the burgeoning cannabis industry. Legal changes have developed that impact all public issuers in the capital markets, and particularly their approach to M&A from both the bidder’s and target’s perspectives.
 
This roundtable will explore these issues and focus on the following questions: what are boards’ views on defensive tactics? How involved is private equity in M&A? Has the regulatory presence decreased as a result of National Instrument 62-104? What has been the role of both activist shareholders and proxy advisory firms in change of control transactions? What lessons does the Aecon transaction provide in terms of Industry Canada’s review process? What should we expect to see in 2019 including in terms of cross-border transactions?
 
Speakers:
 
Anita Anand – Stephen Griggs – Edward Iacobucci – Naizam Kanji
 Jeffrey Lloyd – Stan Magidson – Patricia Olasker
Karrin Powys-Lybbe – Walied Soliman – Robert Yalden
 
General Conference Fee – $100 | Full-Time Academic and Judiciary Rate – $50 |
Free for Full-time Students and Articling Students
 
Tickets Available at: https://bit.ly/2Lr4Zdy
(Registration is free for students)
Please contact Nadia Gulezko (by telephone: 416.978.6767
or by email at n.gulezko@utoronto.ca)

Student Activities

Board Game Night with the Labour & Employment Law Society

Don't know what to do in that awkward lull between class and Called to the Bar? Don't do readings — come eat snacks and play Funemployed with the Labour & Employment Law Society!

Thursday, Oct. 18, 5:30-8 PM, J225

More details here: https://www.facebook.com/events/293747564562228/ 

Pumpkin Carving Contest

U of T Law Pumpkin Carving Contest. 

Date: Tuesday, Oct 31st, 12:30pm

Location: Rowell Room 

Pizza will be provided for those participating. Carving in teams is encouraged. Pumpkins and knives will be provided. 

Email: sara.hubbard@utoronto.ca to signup. 

 

U of T ALS + Osgoode ALSA Joint Social

Come join UofT’s Asia Law Society and Osgoode’s Asian Law Students Association for our unmissable annual joint social. This is a wonderful opportunity to get to know the Asian law student community across both campuses, learn about the events we have planned for the year, and enjoy an ideal Friday evening out with drinks, good food, and delightful company.

Ehwa J Bar is conveniently located near Bloor-Yonge station and no cover or minimum spend is required. If you are planning to attend, please RSVP to this event by clicking the “Going” button so we can be sure that we will be able to accommodate everyone: https://www.facebook.com/events/2167361493519235/

iTrek U of T Law Israel Trip Info Session

Feeling the post-OCI blues? Planning your post-exam getaway already? Come to Israel with your fellow U of T Law students on iTrek!

iTrek is a 7 day trip to Israel from April 27th – May 4th open to all U of T Law students. Over the course of the trip we will explore Israel’s cultural landscape, legal environment, nightlife, high-tech industry, history, and politics. All led by your fellow law students! Come out to the info session to learn more.

Date: Wednesday, Oct. 31st
Time: 12:30 – 1:30pm
Location: TBD

Religious Charities in the Post-TWU Era

On Wednesday, October 17th, at 12:30pm, the Christian Legal Fellowship, Charity Law Interest Group, Jewish Law Students Association, and Muslim Law Students Association present a panel discussion on the future of charity law for religious charities in Canada, in light of the Trinity Western University decision, and other recent developments in charity law.

Panelists include:

Adam Aptowitzer, Managing Partner, Drache Aptowitzer LLP

Barry Bussey, Director of Legal Affairs, Canadian Council of Christian Charities

The event will be held in J130. Pizza lunch to be served. No RSVP required.

Law's #MeToo Moment: Reflections on the Kavanaugh Appointment and Implications for Canadian Legal Culture

On October 6th, the US Senate voted to confirm Brett Kavanaugh's nomination to the Supreme Court. This came after allegations of sexual assault were made against Kavanaugh by three women, including Dr. Christine Blasey Ford, who testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee.

Students and faculty are invited to join us next Thursday, October 18th, 6–8 PM in the Rowell Room for an opportunity to discuss the events surrounding Kavanaugh’s appointment, what it means for efforts to combat sexual violence, and whether it has implications for the Canadian scene. This event is intended to be an open and informal conversation rather than a panel or lecture.

Women & the Law is committed to making this event a safe space for all attendees.

Social Justice Career Panel

Join the U of T Law Union for its annual Social Justice Career Panel! 

Date: Wednesday October 24

Time: 12:30-2PM 

This will be a great opportunity to hear about panelists' career pathways, what a typical day in the office looks like, and the rewards and challenges of working towards social justice through the law. 

Panelists:
- Sarah Beamish, Hensel Barristers 
- Angela Chaisson, Chaisson Law 
- Alexi Wood, St. Lawrence Barristers
- Other panelists TBC

For updated information on the event, including panelists, see here: https://www.facebook.com/events/574469246306850/. 

A vegan lunch will be provided. 

 

CLSA Annual Criminal Law Networking Event

The U of T Criminal Law Students' Association (CLSA) invites you to its first event of the year: the Annual Criminal Law Networking Event! If you're even remotely interested in a career in criminal law, we encourage you to drop by to talk to one of the amazing lawyers and students who have much wisdom to share. This year, our guests include:

-Emily Lam (2008 call, Osgoode grad, Partner at Kastner Law - http://www.kastnerlaw.ca/emily-lam/). Emily is a distinguished criminal defence lawyer, who has worked on dozens of high-profile cases. She was a former partner at Rosen Naster, and a former founding partner at Greenwood Lam. She is currently co-counsel for the appellants on R v Le, scheduled to be heard at the Supreme Court of Canada this week.

-Promise Holmes Skinner (2014 call, U of T grad, articled at Greenspan Humphrey Weinstein (then Greenspan Humphrey Lavine), Sole practitioner). After articling, Promise joined the Aboriginal Legal Services of Toronto as a Senior Manager, all the while practicing criminal defence part-time. She was also the former Manager of Indigenous Initiatives at U of T (then "Aboriginal Law Program Coordinator"), and an Adjunct Professor co-teaching the course, "Aboriginal People and Canadian Criminal Justice".

-Sydney Hopkins (2017 call, U of T grad, articled at Henein Hutchison, now First-Year Associate). While Sydney was a student, she was a Division Leader and Caseworker at Downtown Legal Services in both the Family and Criminal Division.

-Josh Freedman (Articled at Crown Law Office Criminal, current LLM student at U of T and Assistant Crown Attorney at Old City Hall). While Josh was a student, he volunteered at Innocence Canada and summered at Derstine Penman. He also completed a joint MA in Criminology.

-Meghan Zannese (2018 call, U of T grad, articling student at Lockyer Campbell Posner). Meghan also holds a MA in Criminology.

- Daniel Mapa (2018 call, U of T grad, articled at North York Crown Attorney's Office, now Assistant Crown Attorney).

 

 
Some finger food will be provided. What we lack in food, we will make up for in spirit!

If you plan to attend, please RSVP on CLSA's Facebook page or by sending us an e-mail confirmation at uoftlawclsa@gmail.com.

Thursday, October 25th, 6:30pm - 9:00pm
The Firkin on Bloor (81 Bloor St E)
Image may contain: text

Centres, Legal Clinics, and Special Programs

Asper Centre’s 10th Anniversary Celebration

It’s been a full decade since the Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights opened its doors!

To celebrate 10 years of dedicated advocacy, education and research,

former Supreme Court of Canada Justice Thomas Cromwell will moderate a conversation between Mary Eberts and Joseph Arvay, two of our former Constitutional Litigators-in-Residence

on October 17, 2018 at 5:00pm

Jackman Law Building, Faculty of Law, University of Toronto, 78 Queens Park

Reception to follow

REGISTER HERE (for this free event) to help us keep track of numbers

Find out more

Indigenous Initiatives Office and the Asper Centre present: Implicit Bias and Police Decision Making

The Indigenous Initiatives Office and the Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights are pleased to present this special event for law students, faculty and staff only.

Toronto Police Service Detective Sergeant Aly Virji and Sergeant S. Ali Moosvi will talk about the implicit bias training they deliver to all Toronto Police Service officers and why it is important in a diversity city like Toronto. 

1L students wishing to attend the Police Bias event should connect with Waleska Vernon at waleska.vernon@utoronto.ca regarding how they can access the content from the 1L Career Foundations: Career Introductions session they will be missing. 

October 18th in P120 at 12h30-2:00, Light Lunch Provided.

Biographies

Aly Virji – Detective Sergeant – Toronto Police Service

Detective Sergeant Aly Virji has a Master’s Degree in Criminal Justice Administration, and undergraduate degrees in both Kinesiology and Adult Education. He has completed a number of Certificate programs in Police Leadership, Teaching Effectiveness, and Inclusive Leadership.  Aly is also a Canadian Certified Inclusion Professional and is one of the first practitioners to be accredited with the CCIP designation.

Detective Sergeant Aly Virji has 15 years of experience with the Toronto Police Service. He has worked in a number of units including:  Intelligence Services; Human Resources and Strategy Management. He has also been instrumental in designing and delivering presentations and training related to anti-bias with the Fair and Impartial Policing© program and has showcased this work at conferences nationally and internationally. Aly also facilitates training for police officers and health care workers, from across Ontario, on the topic of mental health in the workplace.

Aly represents the Toronto Police Service on the Equity, Diversity & Inclusion Committee of the Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police and as a member of the Board of Directors for the Scarborough Walk of Fame. He has been a keynote and motivational speaker at community events across the GTA and is a tireless volunteer with a particular focus on inspiring young people.

Aly is also an Instructor at Wilfrid Laurier University, in the B.A. in the Policing program, and an Adjunct Professor at George Brown College where he teaches Leadership and Communications courses.

S. Ali Moosvi – Sergeant – Toronto Police Service

Sergeant Ali Moosvi is in the thirtieth year of a diverse policing career ranging from front-line emergency response to major case task force investigations and corporate projects. His experience has helped him become a dynamic presenter and he continues to represent the Toronto Police Service at a variety of venues in Canada and the United States.

Ali is currently studying at Wilfrid Laurier University and working towards completing his Masters of Public Safety. Ali is a strong advocate for improving mental health in the workplace and facilitates training for police officers and health care workers, from across Ontario, on this topic.

Ali has presented at; the 2018 Expert Witness Conference, 2017 Law of Policing Conference, the 2015 Conference of the American Psychological Association’s Division 18, Police and Public Safety Psychologists, and the 2015 Conference of the State and Provincial Police Academy Directors (SPADDS) section of the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP).

Ali remains the only Canadian trainer certified to deliver national implicit bias training-of-trainer courses for the Fair and Impartial Policing© program across Canada and the United States and is regularly recognized for his skill at presenting complex concepts by using real-world experience to effectively enhance learning. Ali has facilitated implicit bias training for police agencies from coast to coast across Canada and recently returned from training supervisors at the NYPD.

For more information and if you have questions, please contact Tal Schreier at tal.schreier@utoronto.ca

or the Manager, Indigenous Initiatives at iio.law@utoronto.ca.

Downtown Legal Services - Employment Law Case Rounds

Interested in the Rights of Workers?  Human Rights?  Current Labour and Employment Law Reforms?  Do you like negotiation?  Being on your feet? 

Come check out the work of the Downtown Legal Services Employment Law Division from the students themselves from 1230 to 2pm on Wednesday October 17th in J140.  Find out about the work we do with clients, drafting materials and advocating at the Human Rights Tribunal, Ontario Labour Relations Board and Small Claims Court.

Bringing Canadian Mining to Justice

Discussion between Human Rights Defender Angélica Choc, her lawyers Murray Klippenstein and Cory Wanless, and Grahame Russell of Rights Action

Monday, October 22, 2018 • 6:15-7:30 pm •

78 Queen’s Park Cres.• Jackman Law Building • Room: J130

Members of the indigenous Mayan Q’eqchi’ population from El Estor, Guatemala are pursuing three related precedent-setting lawsuits in Canadian courts against Canadian mining company HudBay Minerals over se-vere human rights abuses. These cases are the first of their kind in Canada.

Angélica Choc is a Mayan Q’eqchi’ leader and indigenous rights activist from Guatemala. She is the widow of Adolfo Ich Chamán, a respected community leader and school teacher who was brutally murdered by mine company security personnel on September 27, 2009. She will be speaking about her struggle for justice for the murder of her husband both in Canada and in Guatemala.

Cory Wanless and Murray Klippenstein have been Angélica Choc’s lawyers for over nine years. They will be speaking about the current status of the lawsuits against HudBay and the future of litigation in Canada against Canadian companies for human rights abuse abroad. Grahame Russell, Director of Rights Action, will speak about the key role of NGOs in international solidarity work.

Please click here to see event poster.

Information Session: Introduction to IHRP and Asper Centre Summer Fellowship Opportunities

Date: October 25, 2018
Time: 12:30-2:00pm
Location: J140

Please attend this information session to learn more about IHRP and Asper Centre Summer Fellowship opportunities.

PBSC - WestlawNext Canada Legal Research Workshops (Oct. 15th & 25th)

PBSC WestlawNext Canada Legal Research Workshops will be offered on:

- Oct. 15th in J140 at 12:30

- Oct. 25th in P105at 12:30

The PBSC WestlawNext Canada Legal Research Workshop is mandatory for all first year volunteers and all returning volunteers working on research projects - attendance will be taken.

The session offers a truly excellent and unique introduction to legal research that is specific to PBSC and that will not be repetitive with what students will be learning in other LRW classes or sessions.  Students in the past have given very positive feedback.

Students can expect to be provided with an excellent set of materials they can take away with them, that will be useful throughout law school and into articling.

A light meal will be served and awesome Westlaw swag will be distributed!

Career Development Office and Employment Opportunities

Bora Laskin Law Library

BORA LASKIN LIBRARY CLOSURE NOTICE- FRIDAY, OCTOBER 26, 2018 FROM 1:00 PM ONWARD

Due to a special event, the Bora Laskin Library will be closed at 1:00 pm on Friday, October 26, 2018. Rooms FA1 and FA4 (Falconer Hall) have been booked from 2:00 pm – 8:00 pm as alternative study locations. Regular hours will resume on Saturday, October 27, 2018.

Bookstore

Bookstore Hours October and November

Law Bookstore Hours for October 2018

Monday-Thursday 11:30 am - 2:30 pm; Friday 3 pm - 7 pm

Closed Thanksgiving Monday, October 8

Closed Reading Week November 5-9

 

 

 

Fall is Hoodie Season

Come by the bookstore and check out our hoodies!

They're perfect for Fall

 

Book Deals!

Great Deals on Books at the Law Bookstore

$15 for Property on Trial: Canadian Cases in Context. Save 75% off the list price!

$5 for selected old editions of law texts -- check out the titles on the cart in the store

 

Open Mon-Thurs during lunch, 11:30 am - 2:30 pm and Friday afternoon from 3pm-7pm for your study session needs.

External Announcements: Events

Mon, Oct 15: Does Nationhood Promote Egalitarian Justice? Challenging the National Identity Argument (w/ Nils Holtug)

Does Nationhood Promote Egalitarian Justice? Challenging the National Identity Argument

According to the national identity argument, a shared national identity is important for two aspects of social cohesion that, in particular, are required for egalitarian, distributive justice, namely trust and solidarity. I critically discuss the national identity argument as it pertains to social justice. I first provide a more detailed account of the argument. Then I consider, in greater detail, different conceptions of the nation on which the national identity argument may rely. Furthermore, I assess two theoretical arguments for why we should expect national identities to promote social cohesion and so distributive justice. According to the first, a shared identity tends to produce the emotional disposition towards compatriots required for trust and solidarity. According to the second, sharing an identity with someone tends to make their behaviour more predictable which makes it easier to trust them. However, neither of these two accounts of the causal mechanism leading from a national identity to trust and solidarity establishes the need for a national identity, or so I argue. For the purpose of assessing the empirical studies that test the national identity argument, I then decompose the argument in terms of the different elements that may be thought to causally impact social cohesion. On this basis, I survey the empirical evidence for and against the national identity argument. One worry pertaining to these studies is that, very often, they do not appropriately distinguish between different conceptions of the nation, or at least do not do so along the lines that political theorists have thought important. Therefore, I go into greater depth with a recent Danish study I have conducted with two colleagues – a study that aims more specifically to test the impact on trust and solidarity of conservative and liberal nationalist identities. I conclude that, just as the theoretical explanations to which nationalists appeal do not sufficiently support the national identity argument, nor does the empirical evidence that has been gathered so far.

☛ please register here

Nils Holtug
University of Copenhagen
Director, Centre for Advanced Migration Studies
Professor of Political Philosophy
Philosophy Section
Department of Media, Cognition and Communication

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin

Tue, Oct 16: Ethics of AI in Context: Accountable AI Systems (w/ Mark Fox)

Accountable AI Systems 

The most recent advances of AI technology, namely neural networks, and their application to sophisticated pattern recognition tasks, such as image classification in automated vehicles, has led to a plethora of concerns regarding accountability, often couched in terms of the capability of these algorithms to explain their decisions. This presentation will address a different type of accountability: system accountability. We will look at the architecture of intelligent systems that are made of large numbers of intelligent agents and explore the issues and possible solutions to accountability when decisions and actions are the result of large numbers of individual decisions made by interacting intelligent agents.

☛ please register here

Mark S. Fox
University of Toronto
Distinguished Professor of Urban Systems Engineering

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin 

The Deviant Prison: Eastern State Penitentiary and the Advantage of Difference, 1829-1913

The Deviant Prison: Eastern State Penitentiary and the Advantage of Difference, 1829-1913

Dr. Ashley Rubin, Assistant Professor of Sociology, University of Toronto

Ashley Rubin is an assistant professor of sociology at the University of Toronto. Her research examines criminal punishment from historical, sociological, and sociolegal perspectives and has been published in the Law & Society Review,
Law & Social Inquiry, British Journal of Criminology, Punishment & Society,
and Theoretical Criminology, among other venues. Her central project currently is a book manuscript on Eastern State Penitentiary and its exceptional reliance on the Pennsylvania System of long-term solitary confinement.

Date: Friday Oct. 26 , 2018
Time: 12:30pm to 2:00pm
Location: Ericson Seminar Room (room 265)

A light lunch will be served at 12:00 noon in the Lounge.


The talk will begin at 12:30pm in the Ericson Seminar Room (room 265)
Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies,
14 Queen’s Park Crescent West, Toronto, ON Canada, M5S 3K9


If you are a person with a disability and require accommodation, please contact Lori Wells at 416-978-3722 x226 or email lori.wells@utoronto.ca and we will do our best to make appropriate arrangements.

Book Launch: True North Rising with Whit Fraser

Tuesday, October 23, 2018 | 5-7PM | Junior Common Room, Massey College

Please join Massey College's Public Policy program for a talk and reception celebrating the launch of True North Rising by Whit Fraser, former chairman of the Canadian Polar Commission, former executive director of Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, and former CBC journalist. His work took him to every community in Canada’s three northern Territories and much of the circumpolar world. He covered some of the most important stories to the today's Arctic region, including the McKenzie Valley Pipeline Inquiry, Constitutional negotiations that enshrined aboriginal rights in the Canadian Constitution of Canada; Aboriginal Land Claims from initial concept and demands through to the final Agreements.

True North Rising recounts Whit Fraser's involvement with and coverage of these remarkable events and more. His book highlights the extraordinary people who spoke up across Canada’s Northern Territories to challenge the colonial attitudes and policies of the past, bringing lasting change and the prospect of greater justice and equality to come. The book is published by Burnstown Publishing House.

Reception will be held on Tuesday, October 23, 2018 in the Junior Common Room at Massey College. Light refreshments will be served.
RSVP here: https://www.eventbrite.ca/e/book-launch-true-north-rising-with-whit-fraser-tickets-50874153964 

If you have any questions about this event, please contact Emily Tsui at emily.tsui@mail.utoronto.ca

Tues, Oct 16: Ruth Gavison, Israel and the Legacy of World War II

Ruth Gavison
Hebrew University
Faculty of Law

presented by:
Anne Tanenbaum Centre for Jewish Studies

co-sponsored by:
Department of Germanic Languages and Literatures | Centre for Diaspora and Transnational Studies | Centre for Ethics  | Centre for European, Russian, and Eurasian Studies (Munk School of Global Affairs)  | Department of History  | Joint Initiative in German and European Studies and the German Academic Exchange Service | Department of Near and Middle Eastern Civilizations | Konstanty Reynert Chair of Polish History | Al and Malka Green Program in Yiddish Studies

01:00 PM - 02:30 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
Rm 200, Larkin Building

Mon, Oct 22: Author Meets Critics: Hilary Evans Cameron's Refugee Law’s Fact-finding Crisis: Truth, Risk, and the Wrong Mistake (2018)

Refugee Law’s Fact-finding Crisis: Truth, Risk, and the Wrong Mistake (Cambridge 2018)

☛ please register here

Hilary Evans Cameron
Postdoctoral Affiliate, Centre for Ethics
University of Toronto

Commentators:
Amar Bhatia
(Law, York University)
Catherine Bruce 
(Refugee Law Office, Toronto)
Graham Hudson (Criminology, Ryerson)

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
Rm 200, Larkin Building

Tue, Oct 23: Ethics & Film: WALL-E (Ethics of AI Film Series)

☛ please register here

06:00 PM - 08:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
Rm 200, Larkin Building 

Wed, Oct 24: Ethics@Noon: Colin Grey on "Cosmopolitan Pariahs: Exploring the Moral Rationale for Withholding Protection from Criminal Refugees"

Cosmopolitan Pariahs: Exploring the Moral Rationale for Withholding Protection from Criminal Refugees

Article 1F of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees excludes from refugee protection persons guilty of serious international and domestic crimes. Excluded persons are not eligible for refugee status even if they face a well-founded fear of persecution. This paper asks whether a coherent rationale for such exclusion is available, focusing on the influential—and strikingly unexamined—suggestion by UNHCR that Article 1F serves to exclude persons who are “undeserving” of refugee protection. If refugees are persons threatened with violations of their basic human rights, as several philosophical and legal accounts hold, we must ask: What could possibly justify abandoning them to their fate? I will argue that exclusion of refugees for past criminality is best explained as the institutional expression of a form of blame that is appropriate if we accept that all human beings on the Earth exist in a juridical relationship of cosmopolitan right, a Kantian construct that is plausibly seen as the animating idea behind the international refugee regime. The construal of the exclusion clauses as an institutional expression of blame, however, is ultimately inconsistent with a strong human rights reading of the international refugee regime. Instead, the exclusion clauses suggest refugee law represents an institutionalized form of humanitarianism. In other words, the ultimate claim of this paper is that we must choose between exclusion and a strong human rights reading of refugee law. We cannot have both.

Colin Grey
Université du Québec à Montréal
Faculty of Political Science and Law

12:30 PM - 02:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin

Thu, Oct 25: Perspectives on Ethics: Derrick Darby on "Du Bois’s Defense of Democracy"

Du Bois’s Defense of Democracy

I will reconstruct W. E. B. Du Bois’s argument for democracy in Darkwater and draw a lesson about how to address America’s democratic crisis.

☛ please register here

Derrick Darby
University of Michigan
Department of Philosophy

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin 

Tue, Oct 30: Ethics of AI in Context: John Vervaeke on "Why the Creation of A.I. Requires the Cultivation of Wisdom on Our Part"

Why the Creation of A.I. Requires the Cultivation of Wisdom on Our Part

Abstract:  Most considerations concerning the ethics of A.I. are concerned with the ethical issues posed by the potential threat of the machines or concerning their ambiguous moral status and the resulting unclarity of our ethical obligations towards them.  However, a cognitive scientific approach suggests an additional ethical issue. There is converging theory and empirical evidence that while necessary, intelligence in not sufficient for rationality. Rationality requires acquiring skills for overcoming the  biases and the self-deception that inevitably result from any cognitive agent using optimization strategies.  These heuristic strategies often reinforce each other because of the complex and recursively self-organization nature of cognitive processing.  As our A.I. moves increasingly into Artificial General Intelligence (A.G.I), these patterns of self-deception increasing become possible in our machines. This vulnerability is pertinent to us because we are often unaware of our biases or how we are building them implicitly into our simulations of intelligence.  Since self-deception and foolishness are an inevitable result of intelligence, as we magnify intelligence will may also magnify the capacity for self-deception.  Our lack of rational self-correcting  self-awareness could very well be built into our machines. The examination of a couple of historical examples will add plausibility to this argument.  Given this argument, i will further argue that we have an ethical obligation to seriously cultivate a cognitive style of self-correcting self-awareness, i.e., wisdom, in individuals and communities of individuals who are attempting to create A.G.I.

John Vervaeke
University of Toronto
Cognitive Science

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin 

External Announcements: Opportunities

Osler Diversity Scholarship

https://www.osler.com/en/applications/osler-diversity-scholarship

 

Hi everyone!

 

Whether you’re on campus or abroad, I hope you’ve all settled back into your final year of law school. As you can imagine, it has been a busy time here and we’re so grateful for the candidate input you have been providing thus far.  But we miss you!!

 

I’m excited to share information about Osler’s new Diversity Scholarship, a program focused on recognizing law student diversity leaders who are making a difference in either their school, the legal profession or the greater community. The scholarship is focused on incoming second-year law students attending a Canadian law school. Osler will be awarding up to two $2,500 scholarships in early 2019.  To find out more about the program, please visit https://www.osler.com/en/applications/osler-diversity-scholarship.

 

I’m hoping you’ll help to share this award information with the second-year students at your school. Our goal is to ensure that all students are aware of the scholarship and have the opportunity to apply.

 

Thank you for your assistance with spreading the word. Please feel free to reach out with any questions and please don’t be a stranger – would love to hear from you!

 

Christina

 


Christina Beaudoin
Director, Student Programs and Legal Recruitment

416.862.6527 | cbeaudoin@osler.com
Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP | osler.com

Start right. oslerstudents.com

 

 

The William Tetley Award 2019

The Award: The Canadian Maritime Law Association ("CMLA") has established a literary prize, to be called "Professor William Tetley Award" (the "Award").

Purpose: The Honorable William Tetley, CM, QC, President of the Faculty of Law, McGill University, Montreal, for some thirty-five years, in recognition of his outstanding contribution to development of maritime law and maritime law education, both in Canada and around the world.

Nature: The Award will take the form of a monetary prize of between $ 500.00 and $ 1,000.00, to be awarded by Canadian authors of high-quality articles, papers or publications.

Topics: Submissions need not be confined to topics of maritime law, but may be devoted to any subject of an educational nature relevant to the marine industry.

Publication: Winning submissions will be published in the Canadian Maritime Law Association Journal (or republished there with the consent of the copyright holder if already published elsewhere).

Frequency: The Award will not necessarily be issued every year, but only to be awarded by the selection committee of the United States.

Submissions: Submissions (in English or French) may be made by the authors themselves or by anyone acting on their behalf. Submissions should be printed on 8-1 / 2 "x 11" paper, accompanied by an electronic copy on a CD-ROM in pdf format, and sent to:

Mr. P. Jeremy Bolger, 
Chair of the Selection Committee 
Professor William Tetley Award 
c / o Borden Ladner Gervais LLP 
1000 De La Gauchetière West Street, Suite 900 
Montreal, Quebec H3B 5H4.

Submissions must include the name, postal and email addresses and phone number (s) of the author and the submitter (if other than the author). 

Submissions can be made at any time and will be evaluated by the selection committee. The committee will notify the author and submitter of its decision within a reasonable time following receipt of submissions.

For more information, please visit: http://www.cmla.org/tetleyaward.php

J. Stephen Tatrallyay Memorial Award

The Canadian College of Construction Lawyers has established and administers the J. Stephen Tatrallyay Memorial Prize ($1000) given in respect of academic student publishable papers on any current issue of interest to construction law practitioners and topical to the practice of construction law in Canada. The criteria for award of the prize are described in the attached information sheet. The College will select the successful paper in its discretion. Students who have submitted a paper but do not win the monetary prize may still be offered the opportunity to have their paper published in this Journal. 

Call for mentors for the Global Ideas Institute

Now entering its ninth year, the Global Ideas Institute (GII) is pleased to announce the opening of the 2018-2019 Call for Volunteer Mentors! The Global Ideas Institute is an ongoing collaborative program between the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy, University of Toronto Schools, Rotman School of Management’s Integrative Thinking, and World Vision Canada.

 

Mentors are charged with guiding a team of six Grade 11 students throughout the year (October 2018-April 2019) as the team develops an innovative solution to a complex global challenge. Students will work with their mentors once a month until April, where they will present a creative solution to the chosen global problem during a Final Symposium. The global challenge this year is plastic waste management. In the past eight years the Challenge Topics have been: Sustainable Energy for All, Financial Inclusion in India; Scaling the Aravind Eye Institute program; broadening distribution of Sprinkles micronutrient packets; reinventing the toilet; birth registration; sustainable energy access for all; and food security.

 

We are seeking U of T students from a variety of academic disciplines- no background in international development is required. Mentorship or facilitation experience is essential for graduate-level mentors and strongly desired for undergraduate-level mentors. All mentors are expected to devote approximately 3 hours per month to GII, including training, preparation and attendance at all monthly lectures. Please note mentor attendance at every session is critical as GII participants rely heavily on mentor guidance. All GII mentors will receive formal acknowledgement of this role on their official University of Toronto Co-Curricular Record.

 

The GII mentors will come from graduate programs at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education (OISE), the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy, and Rotman School of Management. Undergraduate-level GII mentors will come from Munk One, the Reach Project, and the Trudeau Centre for Peace, Conflict and Justice. Each mentor group will be comprised of two UofT students from the aforementioned programs. These mentor groupings provide ongoing, multitier learning and mentorship opportunities. GII high school students will learn from their team of three mentors and mentors will learn and support each other based on their experience. Mentors will be grouped according to complementary backgrounds and skillsets; the ratio of mentors to students is 2:6.

 

Please apply using this link: https://goo.gl/forms/Skjzv1KveCXBnKdD2

 

If you have any questions about the application, position, or commitment, please feel free to contact the Program Director of the Global Ideas Institute, Kathleen Gnocato, at kathleen.gnocato@utoronto.ca

 

External Announcements: Calls for Papers

Cork Online Law Review 2018/19 Seeking Submissions

 

 

Dear Students,

My name is Elisha Carey and I am Deputy Editor for the 18th Edition of Cork Online Law Review. The Cork Online Law Review at University College Cork, Ireland, is a non-profit Law Review which provides an opportunity for undergraduates and graduates alike to have their work published. The Cork Online Law Review (COLR) was revolutionary when established by law students who had the vision of forming Ireland’s only online law review to be run solely by law students. All articles are peer-reviewed by the UCC Faculty of Law. 

COLR is internationally renowned, having been described by the New York University Law Faculty as 'the leading online law review in Ireland,' and can be viewed at  
http://corkonlinelawreview.com

 
The Editorial Board of the Cork Online Law Review is currently seeking submissions for the 18th Edition which is due to be published online athttp://corkonlinelawreview.com/index.php/category/editions/ and in hard copy in early March 2019. All submissions should be on a legal topic and be between 3000 and 9000 words in length. Submissions are also welcome in Irish, and French. Book reviews and case notes will also be considered. We use the Oxford Style guide as our house style guide. 

There is a medal for the overall best submission, with an accompanying cash prize of €300, as well as a medal for best non-English submission. 

This year we have two deadlines. The initial deadline is the 1st December 2018 and the final deadline is the 21st January 2019. The initial deadline is to facilitate an earlier decision being made on an article. Dependent on the quality of submission received for the initial deadline, the final deadline may involve more competition for publication. I would strongly recommend that you submit as early as possible to the Law Review. 

All interested parties should submit their articles and enquiries to: 

editor@corkonlinelawreview.com

Many thanks, 

Yours faithfully, 

  

Elisha Carey

  

Deputy Editor  

Cork Online Law Review 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

--

Elisha Carey

Deputy Editor-in-Chief, 

Cork Online Law Review

 

www.corkonlinelawreview.com 

Celebrating the Fall Feast: Indigenous Law Students Association holds its annual traditional gathering

Tuesday, October 9, 2018

It was a full house at the annual Fall Feast, September 28th, hosted by the Indigenous Law Students' Association (ILSA). ILSA has been hosting the Fall Feast for many years, and there is evidence of its occurring as far back as the 1980s. This year’s event featured a long table of goodies, including 3 sisters stew, made with corn, bean and squash, and turkey stew, to name a few traditional items. In addition, the event opened with teachings from Elder Bob Philips, toe-tapping music and lots of laughter and discussion among the many guests.

Headnotes - Oct 8 2018

Announcements

Web Site and Headnotes

New video on the website: The Grand Moot

Did you miss the Grand Moot? Want to relive the excitement? The video of the 2018 Grand Moot is now available on the website.

Deans' Offices

Dean’s Drop-in Sessions, Tuesday, October 9, 1.00 p.m. – 2.00 p.m.

Dean Iacobucci will be holding monthly drop in sessions for students to speak one-on-one with him about any questions/concerns/issues/compliments students have about the law school. No appointment is necessary. Just drop by the Martin J. Friedland Dean’s Suite, Rm. J406 in the Jackman Law Building within the allotted drop in time.

Discussion with Justices Ian Binnie and Robert Armstrong

The Honourable Justice Robert Armstrong (formerly of the Court of Appeal for Ontario) offers a course that examines the role of the judge in our judicial system with particular reference to the notion of judicial activism. On Thursday, October 25, 2018 that class will include a visit from the Honourable Ian Binnie (formerly of the Supreme Court of Canada).  Justice Armstrong is opening the class to the entire law school community. Please join them from 12:30 to 2:00 pm in Room P120. RSVP required by the end of the day on Friday, October 19th.

Lawyers Doing Cool Things - Paolo Tonelli J.D/PhD Philosophy 2000

Lawyers Doing Cool Things - Paolo Tonelli, J.D/PhD Philosophy 2000

Tuesday October 9, 2018, 12:30 – 1:30
Room J230 (John Willis classroom)

Sandwiches and water will be provided.

Paolo’s bio: Paolo is the CEO of Codify Legal Publishing Inc., a legal tech start-up that creates automated tools to improve access to the law and practice of law.

As CEO, Paolo oversees all day-to-day operations, including sales, legal and technology; and acts as lead product developer in charge of user experience, product roadmap and industry relations. He regularly liaises with investors and key customers.

Prior to Codify, Paolo was the CEO of CRSTL, a tech company that provided automated legal compliance products for Canadian banks and other financial institutions. Paolo oversaw the sale of the company to Thomson Reuters.

Registration is limited to 20 students. Please click here.

For the full list of fall 2018 Lawyers Doing Cool Things speakers, please click here.

 

Lawyers Doing Cool Things - Zimra Yetnikoff J.D. 2006

Lawyers Doing Cool Things Lunch - Zimra Yetnikoff J.D. 2006

Wednesday October 17, 2018, 12:30 – 1:30
Room J225 (John Willis classroom)

Sandwiches and water will be provided.

Zimra Yitnikoff, J.D. 2006Career profile:  Zimra is Director of Investigations & Hearings at the College of Psychologists of Ontario, where she oversees complaint, discipline, remediation and fitness to practice matters regarding registered psychologists and psychological associates. Prior to becoming Director she was a Case Manager at the College, and was responsible for investigating allegations of professional misconduct.

https://www.linkedin.com/in/zimra-yetnikoff-a1587623/

Registration is limited to 20 students. Please click here

Getting Better at Talking to Everyone - Leadership Skills Workshop

Leadership Skills Workshop - Getting Better at Talking to Everyone

Tuesday October 17th, 12:30 – 2:00, location J125

Workshop description: You have great ideas and are excited to share them with peers, colleagues, and professors. You’ve worked hard, prepared, and did your best to share your vision—still, people didn’t understand.

In this workshop, you’ll learn how to talk about your ideas using language that makes sense to other people. Specifically, you’ll learn simple tools for doing three things better:

  • Thinking about the audience for your ideas (what are they looking for)
  • Getting that audience to listen (compelling stories stand out)
  • Helping that audience understand

This workshop is a great opportunity for all students, especially those who are anxious public speakers, and/or those who are heading into job interviews soon. 

To register, click here

Chris Graham

Chris Graham has been a professional for over a decade. He’s twice been a lawyer: at Sullivan & Cromwell LLP in New York, representing very large banks; and at Pape Salter Teillet LLP in Toronto, representing Aboriginal governments across Canada. (You’d be surprised by the overlap in these two practices. Just ask.)  He is a graduate of the Faculty of Law (J.D. 2006).

Chris is the producer of AMAZING NEW STUFF, a performance series featuring outrageous literary and musical talents in small venues. He’s also an investor in Artery, a platform for making every space a stage.

His writing has appeared in publications in Canada and the USA; he edits a legal encyclopedia; and he regularly tells stories on stages. (He's currently working on a one-person storytelling show called A Child Pets a Kitten with a Hammer, about emotional resiliency in terminal cancer care situations.)

He holds degrees from the University of Oxford (history and politics), University of Toronto (law), and Acadia University (business).

Chris is the founder of TellPeople (www.tellpeople.ca), a vehicle for teaching empathy-based storytelling to professionals.

Student Office

Become a JD Student Ambassador

JD Student Ambassador

 

 

 

 

 

  

VOLUNTEER TO BE A JD STUDENT AMBASSADOR

Did you take a law school tour or attend an admissions info event before you were admitted?  

The JD Admissions Office is seeking JD students in all years to volunteer as JD Ambassadors.

Under the direction of the Senior Recruitment, Admissions & Diversity Outreach Officer, JD Ambassadors will engage with prospective students, applicants and newly admitted students to motivate them to enrol in the Faculty.

________________________________________________________________________________________________

* BE VALUED & MAKE A DIFFERENCE *
You can have a direct impact on the composition of future classes. Incoming students who have interacted with current JD students and alumni consistently rave about the value of their engagement. 
________________________________________________________________________________________________

* EVERYONE IS ENCOURAGED TO PARTICIPATE*
We seek a mix of Ambassadors in order to support the wide range of educational backgrounds, life experiences and demographics of our prospective students and applicants.  
________________________________________________________________________________________________

* REASONABLE TIME COMMITMENT *
The commitment is quite light enough not to be a strain with other commitments. Allot 4-6 hours per term (typically an average of 1 hr /three weeks) to volunteer. We will work around your personal schedule.
________________________________________________________________________________________________

* MAIN DUTIES *

1. LAW SCHOOL TOURS [80%]
Conducting tours that highlight key activities, services, facilities and personnel, and how they relate positively to the student experience. Tour groups range from 1 - 8 people comprising primarily of prospective students, applicants and their relatives/families. Tours are normally 45 min in length, scheduled within the 12:30-2:00 pm period on weekdays. Training will be provided.

2. INFORMATION EVENTS [10%]
Assisting with on-campus and off-campus events, such as Welcome Day, open houses, info sessions and education/career fairs. etc. The majority of events are on weekdays, with possibly 3-5 events held on a weekend day (usually Saturday).

3. E-ENGAGEMENT [10%]
Corresponding with prospective and incoming students via social media, email and live online chats.
________________________________________________________________________________________________

* QUALIFICATIONS *

Candidates must be:
- in ANY JD year of study, from1L to 4L(for combined programs)
- in pursuit of any legal area of interest
- in good academic standing at the Faculty 
- willing and able to be a positive and responsible representative of the Faculty and University

________________________________________________________________________________________________

* SIGN-UP TODAY ONLINE *

To be a new Ambassador
Complete and submit the online application asap at https://goo.gl/forms/4VRvSdFXRLkkVWF23

A resume or cover letter is not required, just the completed online form.
The first round of selections will be made from the applications received by September 18

________________________________________________________________________________________________

* HELP *

Jerome Poon-Ting
Senior Recruitment, Admissions & Diversity Outreach Officer
JD Admissions Office
jerome.poon.ting@utoronto.ca

tel: 416-978-6630

 
 
Academic Support Services at the Law School

Academic Support Program: The ASP connects 1L students with upper-year Academic Advisors who provide one-on-one and small group assistance to those who would like academic support. Our upper year Academic Advisors are Dean’s list students who are keen to provide course-specific advice about summarizing cases, preparing for class, studying for exams, and writing papers. Many of our Academic Advisors used the ASP when they were 1Ls.

The ASP is a free and confidential service. You can access the program as individuals or in small study groups. Please email academic.support@utoronto.ca to book appointments. You will be asked to specify when you are available and which course(s) you would like to focus on.

Learning Strategist:  JD students can book appointments with a Learning Strategist from the University’s Academic Success Centre. Learning Strategists help students tackle challenges associated with heavy reading loads, the lure of procrastination, deadline crunches, and challenges associated with transitioning to a new discipline. To book an appointment please email: kathleen.ogden@utoronto.ca

Writing coaching:  JD students can meet one-on-one with an academic writing instructor who will assist students with specific assignments as well as general writing skills. During a 30-45 minute session, a Professor will read a work-in-progress and offer feedback on organization, documentation, grammar, structure, and punctuation. To book an appointment, please email: jbarbara rose jbarbararose@sympatico.ca

For more details about our academic support services, please go to http://www.law.utoronto.ca/student-life/academic-support

Mindfulness Program: Drop-In Guided Meditation

Take a break and join us for a "Mindful Monday" drop-in guided meditation session.

On October 15th from 1:00pm to 1:30pm, Yukimi Henry will be facilitating a guided mindfulness meditation session in the Quiet Room at the law school (in the basement, near the lockers).

This event is open to all law school community members - students, staff and faculty. A few meditation cushions and yoga mats are available for use, but feel free to bring your own.

No registration is required. We ask that you be arrive just before 1:00pm to avoid disrupting the session once we have begun. For more information email yukimi.henry@utoronto.ca.

MIndfulness Program: "Letting Go of Perfectionism"

U of T MIndfulness Program welcomes back expert facilitator Elli Weisbaum to lead another mindfulness session. Learn about the neuroscience and engage in guided mindfulness practices on the topic of "Letting Go of Perfectionism".

Everyone from the law school community is welcome - students, staff & faculty!

Monday, October 29th
12:30-1:50pm

John Willis Classroom, FL219

A light lunch will be provided. Space is limited so please register in advance. Registration through this link: https://www.eventbrite.ca/e/uoft-law-mindfulness-program-letting-go-of-p...

For questions please contact Yukimi Henry at yukimi.henry@utoronto.ca.

Academic Events

Goodman Lecture: India's Ban on Gay Sex: “Irrational, indefensible, and manifestly arbitrary”

 

“Irrational, indefensible, and manifestly arbitrary.” 

Professor Menaka Guruswamy, Columbia Law School, recently represented gay petitioners in India’s Supreme Court, successfully arguing that India’s ban against consensual gay sex should be struck down.    In its unanimous decision the justices ruled gay Indians are to be accorded all the protections of the Constitution.  She will discuss the case, discussed in this article, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/06/world/asia/india-gay-sex-377.html, during this year’s Goodman Lecture.  The Lecture will take place on Tuesday, October 23, at 4:10 pm in the Moot Court Room.

State of Religious Freedom in Canada

The Law, Religion and Democracy Lab welcomes Mr. Derek B.M. Ross, LLB, LLM, who will speak on the state of religious freedom in Canada post-TWU decision. 

Mr. Ross is the Executive Director and General Counsel of the Christian Legal Fellowship of Canada. 

Please note that this event is held at the same time and place as the Law and Religion seminar. 

Date: October 25, Thursday

Venue: Solarium (FA2)

Time: 2:10 - 4:00 pm

 

 

James Hausman Tax Law & Policy Workshop: Shirley Tillotson

The James Hausman Tax Law & Policy Workshop

presents

Shirley Tillotson
Dalhousie University

New Publics and the Taxman in Canada’s 1950s

Wednesday, October 10, 2018
12:30 - 2:00
Solarium (room FA2), Falconer Hall
84 Queen's Park

Shirley Tillotson is the author of Give and Take: the Citizen-Taxpayer and the Rise of Canadian Democracy, as well as other books and articles on twentieth century Canadian history. She is professor emerita at the University of King's College and an Adjunct Professor (Retired) at the Dalhousie Department of History. She taught Canadian history to undergraduates for 30 years, and her works has received several awards for excellence. Her research in tax history is part of her larger project as an historian of Canada, to explore our distinctive political and legal history in connection to social relations of power. 

A light lunch will be provided.


For additional workshop information, please send an email to events.law@utoronto.ca.

 

Critical Analysis of Law Workshop: Nomi Stolzenberg

CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF LAW WORKSHOP

presents

Nomi Stolzenberg
University of Southern California

Blindspot: Faith-Based Discrimination and the Misinterpretation of 
Sherbert v. Verner

Tuesday, October 9, 2018
12:30 - 2:00
Solarium (Room FA2), Falconer Hall
84 Queen's Park


For additional workshop information, please send an email to events.law@utoronto.ca.

 

Law and Economics Colloquium: Ahmed Taha

LAW & ECONOMICS COLLOQUIUM

presents

Ahmed Taha
Pepperdine University School of Law

Regulating the Advertising of Opinions: An Experimental Investigation
(with John Petrocelli)

Tuesday, October 16, 2018
4:10 - 5:45
Room FL219 (John Willis Classroom)
78 Queen's Park 

Advertisements of many goods and services feature endorsements from consumers who have had atypically positive experiences with them.  Substantial evidence suggests that consumers often erroneously assume that advertised, atypical results are typical.  Thus, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) requires advertisements of atypical results also to disclose the typical results.  However, the FTC has created an exception for advertisements featuring atypically positive opinions regarding a product.  The exception exists because the FTC assumes that consumers believe that advertised opinions only necessarily represent the opinions of the people expressing the opinions.  To test the FTC’s assumption, we conduct a controlled experiment.  We find evidence that, contrary to the FTC’s assumption, consumers believe that an advertised opinion is the typical consumer opinion.  In addition, we find evidence that requiring these advertisements to also disclose the typical consumer opinion would cause consumers to greatly discount advertised atypical opinions. 

Professor Taha's research focuses primarily on consumer and investor protection law. This research reflects both his training in law and in economics in which he holds a Ph.D.  His research has been discussed in national media outlets, including the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal. He is also the Faculty Director of the Palmer Center for Entrepreneurship and the Law.

Prior to joining the Pepperdine faculty, Professor Taha was a professor at Wake Forest Law School, an attorney in the Antitrust Division of the U. S. Department of Justice in Washington, D.C., a litigation associate with Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati in Palo Alto, California, and a corporate finance analyst at McKinsey and Company in New York. Professor Taha teaches Civil Procedure, Corporations, and Accounting and Finance for Lawyers." 

For more workshop information, please send an email to events.law@utoronto.ca

Student Activities

Runnymede Society - Bill 5 Panel

On October 9, the Runnymede Society will be hosting a panel discussion on the legal issues surrounding Bill 5, the controversial legislation that has reduced the size of Toronto’s city council. The constitutionality of the bill was the subject of litigation before the Superior Court of Justice (City of Toronto et al v Ontario) and is currently being appealed to the Ontario Court of Appeal. Further, the bill attracted attention over the Premier's willingness to invoke s. 33, the “notwithstanding clause”, to override the Superior Court’s ruling.

We hope you will join us to hear our speakers' thoughts on this contentious subject. Lunch will be provided.

Our speakers at this event will be:

Rocco Achampong, Applicant in City of Toronto et al v Ontario

Christine Van Geyn, Canadian Taxpayers Federation

Clifton Mark, University of Toronto Centre for Ethics

Asher Honickman, Advocates for the Rule of Law


Date and time: October 9, 12:30 - 2:00 pm

Location: J125, Jackman Law Building

Please RSVP to utoronto@runnymedesociety.ca

Centres, Legal Clinics, and Special Programs

Detention of Asylum Seekers in Israel

Professor Audrey Macklin moderates a discussion with former detainee Osman Ali

Date: Wednesday, October 10, 2018
Time: 12:30-2pm
Location: Room J250

A light lunch will be served.

In 2013, Holot was inaugurated as an open-air detention facility for asylum seekers in Israel. Osman Ali, a young man from Darfur, is featured in a 12-minute Amnesty International film entitled “Holot—The Assault on Human Dignity” where he gives a firsthand account of his experiences. Please join us for a screening of the film to learn more about the people affected by the detention system in Israel. We will hear directly from Ali via Skype and find out how he is working to change the system in the face of challenging circumstances.

Asper Centre’s 10th Anniversary Celebration

It’s been a full decade since the Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights opened its doors!

To celebrate 10 years of dedicated advocacy, education and research,

former Supreme Court of Canada Justice Thomas Cromwell will moderate a conversation between Mary Eberts and Joseph Arvay, two of our former Constitutional Litigators-in-Residence

on October 17, 2018 at 5:00pm

Jackman Law Building, Faculty of Law, University of Toronto, 78 Queens Park

Reception to follow

REGISTER HERE (for this free event) to help us keep track of numbers

Find out more

Indigenous Initiatives Office and the Asper Centre present: Implicit Bias and Police Decision Making

The Indigenous Initiatives Office and the Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights are pleased to present this special event for law students, faculty and staff only.

Toronto Police Service Detective Sergeant Aly Virji and Sergeant S. Ali Moosvi will talk about the implicit bias training they deliver to all Toronto Police Service officers and why it is important in a diversity city like Toronto. 

Biographies

Aly Virji – Detective Sergeant – Toronto Police Service

Detective Sergeant Aly Virji has a Master’s Degree in Criminal Justice Administration, and undergraduate degrees in both Kinesiology and Adult Education. He has completed a number of Certificate programs in Police Leadership, Teaching Effectiveness, and Inclusive Leadership.  Aly is also a Canadian Certified Inclusion Professional and is one of the first practitioners to be accredited with the CCIP designation.

Detective Sergeant Aly Virji has 15 years of experience with the Toronto Police Service. He has worked in a number of units including:  Intelligence Services; Human Resources and Strategy Management. He has also been instrumental in designing and delivering presentations and training related to anti-bias with the Fair and Impartial Policing© program and has showcased this work at conferences nationally and internationally. Aly also facilitates training for police officers and health care workers, from across Ontario, on the topic of mental health in the workplace.

Aly represents the Toronto Police Service on the Equity, Diversity & Inclusion Committee of the Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police and as a member of the Board of Directors for the Scarborough Walk of Fame. He has been a keynote and motivational speaker at community events across the GTA and is a tireless volunteer with a particular focus on inspiring young people.

Aly is also an Instructor at Wilfrid Laurier University, in the B.A. in the Policing program, and an Adjunct Professor at George Brown College where he teaches Leadership and Communications courses.

S. Ali Moosvi – Sergeant – Toronto Police Service

Sergeant Ali Moosvi is in the thirtieth year of a diverse policing career ranging from front-line emergency response to major case task force investigations and corporate projects. His experience has helped him become a dynamic presenter and he continues to represent the Toronto Police Service at a variety of venues in Canada and the United States.

Ali is currently studying at Wilfrid Laurier University and working towards completing his Masters of Public Safety. Ali is a strong advocate for improving mental health in the workplace and facilitates training for police officers and health care workers, from across Ontario, on this topic.

Ali has presented at; the 2018 Expert Witness Conference, 2017 Law of Policing Conference, the 2015 Conference of the American Psychological Association’s Division 18, Police and Public Safety Psychologists, and the 2015 Conference of the State and Provincial Police Academy Directors (SPADDS) section of the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP).

Ali remains the only Canadian trainer certified to deliver national implicit bias training-of-trainer courses for the Fair and Impartial Policing© program across Canada and the United States and is regularly recognized for his skill at presenting complex concepts by using real-world experience to effectively enhance learning. Ali has facilitated implicit bias training for police agencies from coast to coast across Canada and recently returned from training supervisors at the NYPD.

For more information and if you have questions, please contact Tal Schreier at tal.schreier@utoronto.ca

or the Manager, Indigenous Initiatives at iio.law@utoronto.ca.

Career Development Office and Employment Opportunities

Bora Laskin Law Library

BORA LASKIN LIBRARY CLOSURE NOTICE- FRIDAY, OCTOBER 26, 2018 FROM 1:00 PM ONWARD

Due to a special event, the Bora Laskin Library will be closed at 1:00 pm on Friday, October 26, 2018. Rooms FA1 and FA4 (Falconer Hall) have been booked from 2:00 pm – 8:00 pm as alternative study locations. Regular hours will resume on Saturday, October 27, 2018.

Bookstore

Bookstore Hours October and November

Law Bookstore Hours for October 2018

Monday-Thursday 11:30 am - 2:30 pm; Friday 3 pm - 7 pm

Closed Thanksgiving Monday, October 8

Closed Reading Week November 5-9

 

 

 

Fall is Hoodie Season

Come by the bookstore and check out our hoodies!

They're perfect for Fall

 

External Announcements: Events

Wed, Oct 10: Ethics in the City: Human Cities, Posthuman Cities (w/ Mark Kingwell)

Human Cities, Posthuman Cities

Traditional urban philosophy has focussed on the relationship between humans and their built environments. Thus the emphasis on spaces, forms and circulatory systems as conditioned by the physical features of people. A standard injunction of such philosophy would then be to make cities ‘more human’. But what if the standard human body is no longer the baseline for consciousness within cities? In such a case, cities would have to be reconceived at a basic level.

☛ please register here

Mark Kingwell
University of Toronto
Philosophy

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
Rm 200, Larkin Building 

Mon, Oct 15: Does Nationhood Promote Egalitarian Justice? Challenging the National Identity Argument (w/ Nils Holtug)

Does Nationhood Promote Egalitarian Justice? Challenging the National Identity Argument

According to the national identity argument, a shared national identity is important for two aspects of social cohesion that, in particular, are required for egalitarian, distributive justice, namely trust and solidarity. I critically discuss the national identity argument as it pertains to social justice. I first provide a more detailed account of the argument. Then I consider, in greater detail, different conceptions of the nation on which the national identity argument may rely. Furthermore, I assess two theoretical arguments for why we should expect national identities to promote social cohesion and so distributive justice. According to the first, a shared identity tends to produce the emotional disposition towards compatriots required for trust and solidarity. According to the second, sharing an identity with someone tends to make their behaviour more predictable which makes it easier to trust them. However, neither of these two accounts of the causal mechanism leading from a national identity to trust and solidarity establishes the need for a national identity, or so I argue. For the purpose of assessing the empirical studies that test the national identity argument, I then decompose the argument in terms of the different elements that may be thought to causally impact social cohesion. On this basis, I survey the empirical evidence for and against the national identity argument. One worry pertaining to these studies is that, very often, they do not appropriately distinguish between different conceptions of the nation, or at least do not do so along the lines that political theorists have thought important. Therefore, I go into greater depth with a recent Danish study I have conducted with two colleagues – a study that aims more specifically to test the impact on trust and solidarity of conservative and liberal nationalist identities. I conclude that, just as the theoretical explanations to which nationalists appeal do not sufficiently support the national identity argument, nor does the empirical evidence that has been gathered so far.

☛ please register here

Nils Holtug
University of Copenhagen
Director, Centre for Advanced Migration Studies
Professor of Political Philosophy
Philosophy Section
Department of Media, Cognition and Communication

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin

Tue, Oct 16: Ethics of AI in Context: Accountable AI Systems (w/ Mark Fox)

Accountable AI Systems 

The most recent advances of AI technology, namely neural networks, and their application to sophisticated pattern recognition tasks, such as image classification in automated vehicles, has led to a plethora of concerns regarding accountability, often couched in terms of the capability of these algorithms to explain their decisions. This presentation will address a different type of accountability: system accountability. We will look at the architecture of intelligent systems that are made of large numbers of intelligent agents and explore the issues and possible solutions to accountability when decisions and actions are the result of large numbers of individual decisions made by interacting intelligent agents.

☛ please register here

Mark S. Fox
University of Toronto
Distinguished Professor of Urban Systems Engineering

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin 

The Deviant Prison: Eastern State Penitentiary and the Advantage of Difference, 1829-1913

The Deviant Prison: Eastern State Penitentiary and the Advantage of Difference, 1829-1913

Dr. Ashley Rubin, Assistant Professor of Sociology, University of Toronto

Ashley Rubin is an assistant professor of sociology at the University of Toronto. Her research examines criminal punishment from historical, sociological, and sociolegal perspectives and has been published in the Law & Society Review,
Law & Social Inquiry, British Journal of Criminology, Punishment & Society,
and Theoretical Criminology, among other venues. Her central project currently is a book manuscript on Eastern State Penitentiary and its exceptional reliance on the Pennsylvania System of long-term solitary confinement.

Date: Friday Oct. 26 , 2018
Time: 12:30pm to 2:00pm
Location: Ericson Seminar Room (room 265)

A light lunch will be served at 12:00 noon in the Lounge.


The talk will begin at 12:30pm in the Ericson Seminar Room (room 265)
Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies,
14 Queen’s Park Crescent West, Toronto, ON Canada, M5S 3K9


If you are a person with a disability and require accommodation, please contact Lori Wells at 416-978-3722 x226 or email lori.wells@utoronto.ca and we will do our best to make appropriate arrangements.

Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies Speaker Series Fall 2018 Schedule

CrimSL Speaker Series Fall 2018 Schedule

Friday, Oct. 26, 2018
“The Deviant Prison: Eastern State Penitentiary and the Advantage of Difference,1829–1913”
Dr. Ashley Rubin, Assistant Professor of Sociology, University of Toronto

Friday, Nov. 23, 2018
“Gacaca, Genocide, Genocide Ideology: The Violent Aftermaths of Transitional Justice in the New Rwanda”
Dr. Mark Anthony Geraghty, Andrew W. Mellon Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Jackman Humanities Institute, University of Toronto

Thursday, Dec. 6, 2018
“Rights on Trial: How U.S. Workplace Discrimination Law Perpetuates Inequality”
Dr. Ellen Berrey, Assistant Professor of Sociology at the University of Toronto and an affiliated scholar of the American Bar Foundation

Unless otherwise specified, talks are held in CrimSL’s Ericson Seminar Room, room 265 at 14 Queen’s Park Crescent West.

A light lunch will be served at 12:00 noon in the CrimSL lounge


If you are a person with a disability and require accommodation, please contact Lori Wells at 416-978-3722 x226 or email lori.wells@utoronto.ca and we will do our best to make appropriate arrangements.

Fri, Oct 12: Ethics of AI in Predictive Policing

☛ please register here

Presenter:
Prof. Dr. E.G. Rajan

President & Chairman
Pentagram Group of Companies

http://www.pentagramresearch.com

Commentator:
Kelly Hannah-Moffat
University of Toronto

Professor of Sociology
Vice-President, Human Resources & Equity
 

12:00 PM - 02:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto 
Rm 200, Larkin Building

Book Launch: True North Rising with Whit Fraser

Tuesday, October 23, 2018 | 5-7PM | Junior Common Room, Massey College

Please join Massey College's Public Policy program for a talk and reception celebrating the launch of True North Rising by Whit Fraser, former chairman of the Canadian Polar Commission, former executive director of Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, and former CBC journalist. His work took him to every community in Canada’s three northern Territories and much of the circumpolar world. He covered some of the most important stories to the today's Arctic region, including the McKenzie Valley Pipeline Inquiry, Constitutional negotiations that enshrined aboriginal rights in the Canadian Constitution of Canada; Aboriginal Land Claims from initial concept and demands through to the final Agreements.

True North Rising recounts Whit Fraser's involvement with and coverage of these remarkable events and more. His book highlights the extraordinary people who spoke up across Canada’s Northern Territories to challenge the colonial attitudes and policies of the past, bringing lasting change and the prospect of greater justice and equality to come. The book is published by Burnstown Publishing House.

Reception will be held on Tuesday, October 23, 2018 in the Junior Common Room at Massey College. Light refreshments will be served.
RSVP here: https://www.eventbrite.ca/e/book-launch-true-north-rising-with-whit-fraser-tickets-50874153964 

If you have any questions about this event, please contact Emily Tsui at emily.tsui@mail.utoronto.ca

Muslim Women In Politics panel discussion

The Muslim Women in Politics Panel aims to discuss the challenges Muslim women face in the political sphere - challenges like sexism, racism, Islamophobia and social media abuse that are magnified in the world of politics. Hosting prominent local and federal politicians (MP Yasmin Ratansi, MPP Doly Begum, TDSB Ward 19 candidate Samiya Abdi and Community Relations Expert, Urz Heer), the event will discuss the women's personal experiences campaigning and serving in office. With the Toronto municipal elections coming up shortly and the federal elections just a year away, we hope to generate a pertinent and timely discussion on the challenges Muslim women in politics face and the way these challenges relate to broader developments in Canadian multiculturalism. Individuals can RSVP through the Facebook event page at https://www.facebook.com/events/289431428328680/ 

U of T Cyber Security Awareness Month - panel discussion

Information Technology Services (ITS) presents a panel discussion about how University of Toronto students, staff and faculty can incorporate cyber security awareness into their everyday lives. Panelists will address common queries regarding cyber security along with answer questions submitted from the audience in person and via social media.

 

Date: Oct. 10

Time: 12 p.m. – 1:00 p.m.

Location: Bahen Centre, Room 1170

Prizes and giveaways
Register

 

Panelists

  • Sue McGlashan, information security architect, Information Security and Enterprise Architecture
  • Alex Tichine, associate director, information security and enterprise systems, Faculty of Engineering and Applied Science
  • Carl Chan, senior systems and network analyst, Education Commons, Ontario Institute for Studies in Education

Moderator

  • John Latremouille, director, information technology services, Rotman

Find out more

External Announcements: Opportunities

Osler Diversity Scholarship

https://www.osler.com/en/applications/osler-diversity-scholarship

 

Hi everyone!

 

Whether you’re on campus or abroad, I hope you’ve all settled back into your final year of law school. As you can imagine, it has been a busy time here and we’re so grateful for the candidate input you have been providing thus far.  But we miss you!!

 

I’m excited to share information about Osler’s new Diversity Scholarship, a program focused on recognizing law student diversity leaders who are making a difference in either their school, the legal profession or the greater community. The scholarship is focused on incoming second-year law students attending a Canadian law school. Osler will be awarding up to two $2,500 scholarships in early 2019.  To find out more about the program, please visit https://www.osler.com/en/applications/osler-diversity-scholarship.

 

I’m hoping you’ll help to share this award information with the second-year students at your school. Our goal is to ensure that all students are aware of the scholarship and have the opportunity to apply.

 

Thank you for your assistance with spreading the word. Please feel free to reach out with any questions and please don’t be a stranger – would love to hear from you!

 

Christina

 


Christina Beaudoin
Director, Student Programs and Legal Recruitment

416.862.6527 | cbeaudoin@osler.com
Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP | osler.com

Start right. oslerstudents.com

 

 

The William Tetley Award 2019

The Award: The Canadian Maritime Law Association ("CMLA") has established a literary prize, to be called "Professor William Tetley Award" (the "Award").

Purpose: The Honorable William Tetley, CM, QC, President of the Faculty of Law, McGill University, Montreal, for some thirty-five years, in recognition of his outstanding contribution to development of maritime law and maritime law education, both in Canada and around the world.

Nature: The Award will take the form of a monetary prize of between $ 500.00 and $ 1,000.00, to be awarded by Canadian authors of high-quality articles, papers or publications.

Topics: Submissions need not be confined to topics of maritime law, but may be devoted to any subject of an educational nature relevant to the marine industry.

Publication: Winning submissions will be published in the Canadian Maritime Law Association Journal (or republished there with the consent of the copyright holder if already published elsewhere).

Frequency: The Award will not necessarily be issued every year, but only to be awarded by the selection committee of the United States.

Submissions: Submissions (in English or French) may be made by the authors themselves or by anyone acting on their behalf. Submissions should be printed on 8-1 / 2 "x 11" paper, accompanied by an electronic copy on a CD-ROM in pdf format, and sent to:

Mr. P. Jeremy Bolger, 
Chair of the Selection Committee 
Professor William Tetley Award 
c / o Borden Ladner Gervais LLP 
1000 De La Gauchetière West Street, Suite 900 
Montreal, Quebec H3B 5H4.

Submissions must include the name, postal and email addresses and phone number (s) of the author and the submitter (if other than the author). 

Submissions can be made at any time and will be evaluated by the selection committee. The committee will notify the author and submitter of its decision within a reasonable time following receipt of submissions.

For more information, please visit: http://www.cmla.org/tetleyaward.php

J. Stephen Tatrallyay Memorial Award

The Canadian College of Construction Lawyers has established and administers the J. Stephen Tatrallyay Memorial Prize ($1000) given in respect of academic student publishable papers on any current issue of interest to construction law practitioners and topical to the practice of construction law in Canada. The criteria for award of the prize are described in the attached information sheet. The College will select the successful paper in its discretion. Students who have submitted a paper but do not win the monetary prize may still be offered the opportunity to have their paper published in this Journal. 

LDCT workshop: Paolo Tonelli, J.D./PhD Philosophy 2000

Use the form below to register for the following Lawyers Doing Cool Things event:

Paolo Tonelli, J.D./PhD Philosophy 2000
Tuesday October 9, 2018, 12:30 – 2:00
Room J230 
Sandwiches and water will be provided.

More than $2.5 million has been raised to support a chair and JD/MBA student financial awards at the University of Toronto in honour of the late Geoff Taber

Thursday, October 4, 2018

More than $2.5 million has been raised to support a chair and JD/MBA student financial awards at the University of Toronto in honour of the late Geoff Taber

More than $2.5 million has been raised to support a chair and JD/MBA student financial awards at the University of Toronto in honour of the late Geoff Taber, who tragically perished with his wife, Jacquie and two teenaged sons, in a fire on December 24, 2016.

Headnotes - Oct 1 2018

Announcements

Web Site and Headnotes

Deans' Offices

Faculty Council, Wednesday, October 3, 2018

12.30 p.m. – 2.00 p.m. - Solarium

All students are welcome to attend meetings of the law school’s faculty council . Materials are available for viewing beforehand on the Faculty of Law website. Please log-on to e-legal, click on My Resources, then Faculty Council.  Please note: seating at the table is reserved for Faculty Council members only.

Registering with Accessibility Services

Important Reminder:  

For students with on-going conditions or disabilities (including mental health issues) that impact the writing of exams and/or papers, it is critically important to register with the University's Accessibility Services as soon as possible. If testing accommodations are required (extra time, separate testing facilities), students must also register with the University's Test & Exam Services.

Registration packages and further information about Accessibility Services deadlines can be found here. Registration information for Test & Exam Services can be found here.

Please note that Accessibility Services can also assist students with accessing note taking services, assistive devices, and potential funding for additional academic supports.

Accessibility Services is a central University service that sets its own deadlines. Students must refer directly to Accessibility Services’ web site to stay on top of those deadlines. Students who register after the deadline typically are not able to write exams during the regular examination period with accommodations. 

Some academic accommodations offered through the law school are available for students experiencing unexpected or urgent circumstances that render them unable to complete their examinations or written materials. The law school can provide a deferral or extension for students who meet the criteria for accommodation. For more information on the process for requesting an accommodation through the law school see the Academic Handbook for more information.

We are very happy to help you navigate this process.  Please contact me at alexis.archbold@utoronto.ca, or Yukimi Henry at Yukimi.henry@utoronto.ca if you have any questions.

 

 

Nominations for 2019 Ann Wilson and Robert Prichard Award for Community and Professional Service

The Ann Wilson and Robert Prichard for Community and Professional Service Award honours a recent graduate of the Faculty of Law (5-15 years since graduation) who demonstrates the highest standards of professional integrity, excellence and leadership, and who has made a significant contribution to the legal profession and/or community through their public interest work, pro bono activities and/or community service.  The recipient will be selected by the Law Alumni Association Council Nominations Sub-Committee and the award will be presented bi-annually at the Distinguished Alumni Award ceremony.

The 2019 Distinguished Alumni Award ceremony will be held in Spring 2019. It is expected that the Wilson Prichard Award recipient is available to accept their award in person; the date for the ceremony will be announced in late Fall 2018.

Nominate Here

Discussion with Justices Ian Binnie and Robert Armstrong

The Honourable Justice Robert Armstrong (formerly of the Court of Appeal for Ontario) offers a course that examines the role of the judge in our judicial system with particular reference to the notion of judicial activism. On Thursday, October 4, 2017 that class will include a visit from the Honourable Ian Binnie (formerly of the Supreme Court of Canada).  Justice Armstrong is opening the class to the entire law school community. Please join them from 12:30 to 2:00 pm in Room P120. RSVP required by the end of the day on Friday, October 19th.

Emerging Issues Workshop: Perspectives on the Legalization of Cannabis

Emerging Issues Workshop Series

Perspectives on the Legalization of Cannabis

Thursday October 4th 

12:30-1:45 pm

Jackman Law Building #J125

 Panelists: Stephanie DiGiuseppe, Counsel at Ruby Shiller Enenajor DiGiuseppe; Professor Akwasi Owusu-Bempah, Department of Sociology (UTM); and Professor Kent Roach, Faculty of Law

The Emerging Issues Workshop Series is back for its 3rd year! Join us for the 2018/19 kick-off event on the topic of marijuana legalization and the amnesty movement.

Topics of discussion will include:

  • What has been the impact of Canada’s war on drugs?
  • What populations have been most affected by cannabis prohibition & how have their lives been impacted?
  • How can we repair the harms caused to those with convictions as we move towards a legalized cannabis regime?
  • What are the arguments in favour of granting amnesty to those with convictions for cannabis possession?

Pizza lunch will be served.  Registration is not required, but capacity is limited. 

Come early to avoid disappointment!

This event is being held in conjunction with the University’s Centre for Criminology and Sociolegal Studies.

Proposed Intersession term in 2019-20

Dear University of Toronto Faculty of Law Community,

 

This fall, the Faculty of Law's Curriculum Committee will recommend to Faculty Council its support of an intercession term starting in 2019-2020.  Attached is a brief memo written by the Curriculum Committee that outlines the key terms of the proposed intercession and the path the Committee took to reach its recommendation.  The Curriculum Committee welcomes feedback from the students and faculty, either in person with the committee (dates outlined on the memo) or by writing to associatedean.law@utoronto.ca

 

Sincerely,

 

The Curriculum Committee: Zachary Biech (3L), Brendan Cassidy (2L), Mohammad Fadel, Sara Faherty, Larissa Katz, Sophia Moreau, Richard Stacey, Catherine Valcke, Albert Yoon

Student Office

Become a JD Student Ambassador

JD Student Ambassador

 

 

 

 

 

  

VOLUNTEER TO BE A JD STUDENT AMBASSADOR

Did you take a law school tour or attend an admissions info event before you were admitted?  

The JD Admissions Office is seeking JD students in all years to volunteer as JD Ambassadors.

Under the direction of the Senior Recruitment, Admissions & Diversity Outreach Officer, JD Ambassadors will engage with prospective students, applicants and newly admitted students to motivate them to enrol in the Faculty.

________________________________________________________________________________________________

* BE VALUED & MAKE A DIFFERENCE *
You can have a direct impact on the composition of future classes. Incoming students who have interacted with current JD students and alumni consistently rave about the value of their engagement. 
________________________________________________________________________________________________

* EVERYONE IS ENCOURAGED TO PARTICIPATE*
We seek a mix of Ambassadors in order to support the wide range of educational backgrounds, life experiences and demographics of our prospective students and applicants.  
________________________________________________________________________________________________

* REASONABLE TIME COMMITMENT *
The commitment is quite light enough not to be a strain with other commitments. Allot 4-6 hours per term (typically an average of 1 hr /three weeks) to volunteer. We will work around your personal schedule.
________________________________________________________________________________________________

* MAIN DUTIES *

1. LAW SCHOOL TOURS [80%]
Conducting tours that highlight key activities, services, facilities and personnel, and how they relate positively to the student experience. Tour groups range from 1 - 8 people comprising primarily of prospective students, applicants and their relatives/families. Tours are normally 45 min in length, scheduled within the 12:30-2:00 pm period on weekdays. Training will be provided.

2. INFORMATION EVENTS [10%]
Assisting with on-campus and off-campus events, such as Welcome Day, open houses, info sessions and education/career fairs. etc. The majority of events are on weekdays, with possibly 3-5 events held on a weekend day (usually Saturday).

3. E-ENGAGEMENT [10%]
Corresponding with prospective and incoming students via social media, email and live online chats.
________________________________________________________________________________________________

* QUALIFICATIONS *

Candidates must be:
- in ANY JD year of study, from1L to 4L(for combined programs)
- in pursuit of any legal area of interest
- in good academic standing at the Faculty 
- willing and able to be a positive and responsible representative of the Faculty and University

________________________________________________________________________________________________

* SIGN-UP TODAY ONLINE *

To be a new Ambassador
Complete and submit the online application asap at https://goo.gl/forms/4VRvSdFXRLkkVWF23

A resume or cover letter is not required, just the completed online form.
The first round of selections will be made from the applications received by September 18

________________________________________________________________________________________________

* HELP *

Jerome Poon-Ting
Senior Recruitment, Admissions & Diversity Outreach Officer
JD Admissions Office
jerome.poon.ting@utoronto.ca

tel: 416-978-6630

 
 
Academic Support Services at the Law School

Academic Support Program: The ASP connects 1L students with upper-year Academic Advisors who provide one-on-one and small group assistance to those who would like academic support. Our upper year Academic Advisors are Dean’s list students who are keen to provide course-specific advice about summarizing cases, preparing for class, studying for exams, and writing papers. Many of our Academic Advisors used the ASP when they were 1Ls.

The ASP is a free and confidential service. You can access the program as individuals or in small study groups. Please email academic.support@utoronto.ca to book appointments. You will be asked to specify when you are available and which course(s) you would like to focus on.

Learning Strategist:  JD students can book appointments with a Learning Strategist from the University’s Academic Success Centre. Learning Strategists help students tackle challenges associated with heavy reading loads, the lure of procrastination, deadline crunches, and challenges associated with transitioning to a new discipline. To book an appointment please email: kathleen.ogden@utoronto.ca

Writing coaching:  JD students can meet one-on-one with an academic writing instructor who will assist students with specific assignments as well as general writing skills. During a 30-45 minute session, a Professor will read a work-in-progress and offer feedback on organization, documentation, grammar, structure, and punctuation. To book an appointment, please email: jbarbara rose jbarbararose@sympatico.ca

For more details about our academic support services, please go to http://www.law.utoronto.ca/student-life/academic-support

Academic Events

India's Ban on Gay Sex: “Irrational, indefensible, and manifestly arbitrary”

 

“Irrational, indefensible, and manifestly arbitrary.” 

Professor Menaka Guruswamy, Columbia Law School, recently represented gay petitioners in India’s Supreme Court, successfully arguing that India’s ban against consensual gay sex should be struck down.    In its unanimous decision the justices ruled gay Indians are to be accorded all the protections of the Constitution.  She will discuss the case, discussed in this article, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/06/world/asia/india-gay-sex-377.html, during this year’s Goodman Lecture.  The Lecture will take place on Tuesday, October 23, at 4:10 pm in the Moot Court Room.

Law and Economics Colloquium: Kathryn Judge

LAW & ECONOMICS COLLOQUIUM

presents

Kathryn Judge
Columbia Law School

Guarantor of Last Resort

Tuesday, October 2, 2018
4:10 - 5:45
Room FL219 (John Willis Classroom)
78 Queen's Park 

The optimal response to a financial crisis entails addressing two, often conflicting, demands: stopping the panic and starting the clock. When short-term depositors flee, banks can be forced to sell assets at fire-sale prices, causing credit to contract and real economic activity to decline. To reduce these adverse spillover effects, governments routinely intervene to stop systemic runs. All too often, however, they deploy stopgap measures that allow the underlying problems to fester.  To promote long-term economic health, policymakers must also ferret out the underlying problems and allocate the losses that cannot be avoided.  An appropriately designed guarantor of last resort can address these conflicting demands.  Just-in-time guarantees keep private capital in the system, providing policymakers the time that they need to develop a viable plan to address deficiencies. A strict time limit on those guarantees ensures that policymakers and market participants remain motivated to devise such a plan, avoiding the alternative pitfall of excessive forbearance.    

Kathryn Judge is a Professor of Law at Columbia Law School. Judge is an editor of the Journal of Financial Regulation and serves on the Financial Research Advisory Council of the Office of Financial Research. She is an expert on financial markets and regulation, including banking, the 2008 financial crisis, regulatory architecture, central bank governance, and regulatory accountability.  She has had two articles selected by peers as among the top business law articles of the year and her scholarship has been published in numerous leading journals, including the Stanford Law Review, Harvard Law Review, The University of Chicago Law Review, Virginia Law Review, and Columbia Law Review.  Prior to joining the Law School, Judge clerked for Judge Richard Posner of the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals and Justice Stephen Breyer of the Supreme Court. She also worked as a corporate associate with Latham & Watkins. She is a graduate of Stanford Law School, where she earned the Urban A. Sontheimer Honor (second in class), and Wesleyan University.

 For more workshop information, please send an email to events.law@utoronto.ca

 

State of Religious Freedom in Canada

The Law, Religion and Democracy Lab welcomes Mr. Derek B.M. Ross, LLB, LLM, who will speak on the state of religious freedom in Canada post-TWU decision. 

Mr. Ross is the Executive Director and General Counsel of the Christian Legal Fellowship of Canada. 

Please note that this event is held at the same time and place as the Law and Religion seminar. 

Date: October 25, Thursday

Venue: Solarium (FA2)

Time: 2:10 - 4:00 pm

 

 

Mary and Philip Seeman Health Law, Policy & Ethics Seminar Series: Donrich W. Thaldar

MARY AND PHILIP SEEMAN HEALTH LAW, POLICY & ETHICS SEMINAR SERIES

presents

Donrich W. Thaldar
School of Law
University of KwaZulu-Natal

Tradition and Justice: 
Legal Developments Relating to New Reproductive Technologies in South Africa

Commentator:
Cheryl Milne, Director
Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights
University of Toronto

Thursday, October 4, 2018 
12:30 - 2:00 
Solarium (room FA2), Falconer Hall 
84 Queen's Park

Similar to Canadian law, South African law allows altruistic surrogate motherhood. However, South African law requires that the commissioning parents must use their own gametes for the conception of the surrogacy child . This statutory requirement was challenged in the South African courts as being contrary to the commissioning parents’ constitutional rights to, amongst others, dignity, privacy, and equality. Although this constitutional challenge was successful in the Pretoria High Court, a 7–4 majority of South Africa’s Constitutional Court decided against the constitutional challenge. This seminar critically examines the main arguments for and against the requirement that commissioning parents must use their own gametes for the conception of the surrogacy child.

Donrich W. Thaldar is an academic at the Law School of the University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban. His academic research interests are bioethics, bio-innovation and intellectual property law. He also practices as a litigation lawyer, where he focuses on strategic human rights cases. He has acted as legal counsel in four cases before South Africa’s Constitutional Court — the country’s apex court. His most recent litigation success was South Africa’s first case of posthumous conception.

A light lunch will be provided. 

For more information about this workshop, please send an e-mail to events.law@utoronto.ca 

James Hausman Tax Law & Policy Workshop: Shirley Tillotson

The James Hausman Tax Law & Policy Workshop

presents

Shirley Tillotson
Dalhousie University

New Publics and the Taxman in Canada’s 1950s

Wednesday, October 10, 2018
12:30 - 2:00
Solarium (room FA2), Falconer Hall
84 Queen's Park

Shirley Tillotson is the author of Give and Take: the Citizen-Taxpayer and the Rise of Canadian Democracy, as well as other books and articles on twentieth century Canadian history. She is professor emerita at the University of King's College and an Adjunct Professor (Retired) at the Dalhousie Department of History. She taught Canadian history to undergraduates for 30 years, and her works has received several awards for excellence. Her research in tax history is part of her larger project as an historian of Canada, to explore our distinctive political and legal history in connection to social relations of power. 

A light lunch will be provided.


For additional workshop information, please send an email to events.law@utoronto.ca.

 

Critical Analysis of Law Workshop: Nomi Stolzenberg

CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF LAW WORKSHOP

presents

Nomi Stolzenberg
University of Southern California

Blindspot: Faith-Based Discrimination and the Misinterpretation of 
Sherbert v. Verner

Tuesday, October 9, 2018
12:30 - 2:00
Solarium (Room FA2), Falconer Hall
84 Queen's Park


For additional workshop information, please send an email to events.law@utoronto.ca.

 

Student Activities

How to Host an Event at the Law School

How to host an event at the law school.

The Faculty of Law is pleased to support students to host events at the law school. Some of the events that students have hosted at the law school include speaker events, panel events, parties, meetings, conferences, socials, and lunches. Students are encouraged to contact the Student Programs Coordinator to discuss event planning: sara.hubbard@utoronto.ca

Booking space:

The Faculty of Law offers free space for law school student organizations to host meetings and events. All students have access to the Rowell Room and the JD Student Lounge between 9-5 on days when classes are held. Barring special circumstances, this is not bookable space during this time and students can host small meetings and get-togethers. Students are not permitted to use library space to host events. To book private space at the law school, students should sign into e.legal on the main U of T Law website: https://www.law.utoronto.ca/ and click on “book a room.” Students can check which rooms are available by clicking “book a room” and then choosing “room availability” from the left-hand list.

If you are part of a student organization at the Faculty of Law, you may want to register as an official student group at the University of Toronto. Registering as an official U of T group gives you access to other bookable space outside of the law school free of charge.

To register as an official U of T Student group, go here: https://www.ulife.utoronto.ca/

Catering/Food at the law school:

We are fortunate at the law school to have no restrictions on catering and food vendors. The law school has relationships with Sushi Inn, Red Rooster, Santaguida, Innis College Catering, and St. George Catering. However, students can order from all catering and take out restaurants.

All events that serve alcohol must use Campus Beverage Services and receive approval from the Student Programs Coordinator.

Students are expected to clean up after themselves and leave the space in the condition they found it in. This means picking up dropped food, wiping down tables, and removing garbage from the space.

Funding

All funding requests should be directed to the SLS through the consolidated funding request form found on the SLS website: https://studentslawsociety.wordpress.com/

Student groups and individual students are not permitted to fundraise from law firms. However, if a student group received funding in the previous academic year from a particular firm, they are permitted to continuing asking this firm for the same level of funding for the same event.

Marketing

Put your event on Headnotes by signing into e.legal and clicking on “submit headnotes announcement.”

To have your event added to the online law school calendar, please email: events.law@utoronto.ca with the name, date, location, blurb, and whether you would like your event listed as public or law school only.

Post your event on the SLS Facebook Group.

 

Intro to Business Law Panel

Tuesday, October 2, 12:30 - 2:00

Room P120

 

Join the Business Law Society for a panel discussion with several U of T Law alumni who are now practicing business law in Toronto. Discover the range of opportunities available within the realm of business law. The event will include a moderated discussion among the panelists plus a Q&A period. 

Lunch will be served!

Panelists include:
Elizabeth Breen, Partner - Stikeman Elliott
Koker Christensen, Partner & Co-Leader of Financial Institutions Group - Fasken
Alyssa Shivji, Associate - Blake, Cassels & Graydon
Shauvik Shah, Associate - McCarthy Tetrault
Tara Hunt, Associate - Goodmans

https://www.facebook.com/events/887101801489196/

 

Centres, Legal Clinics, and Special Programs

Detention of Asylum Seekers in Israel

Professor Audrey Macklin moderates a discussion with former detainee Osman Ali

Date: Wednesday, October 10, 2018
Time: 12:30-2pm
Location: Room J250

A light lunch will be served.

In 2013, Holot was inaugurated as an open-air detention facility for asylum seekers in Israel. Osman Ali, a young man from Darfur, is featured in a 12-minute Amnesty International film entitled “Holot—The Assault on Human Dignity” where he gives a firsthand account of his experiences. Please join us for a screening of the film to learn more about the people affected by the detention system in Israel. We will hear directly from Ali via Skype and find out how he is working to change the system in the face of challenging circumstances.

Asper Centre’s 10th Anniversary Celebration

It’s been a full decade since the Asper Centre for Constitutional Rights opened its doors!

To celebrate 10 years of dedicated advocacy, education and research,

former Supreme Court of Canada Justice Thomas Cromwell will moderate a conversation between Mary Eberts and Joseph Arvay, two of our former Constitutional Litigators-in-Residence

on October 17, 2018 at 5:00pm

Jackman Law Building, Faculty of Law, University of Toronto, 78 Queens Park

Reception to follow

REGISTER HERE (for this free event) to help us keep track of numbers

Find out more

Career Development Office and Employment Opportunities

Bookstore

Bookstore Hours October and November

Law Bookstore Hours for October 2018

Monday-Thursday 11:30 am - 2:30 pm; Friday 3 pm - 7 pm

Closed Thanksgiving Monday, October 8

Closed Reading Week November 5-9

 

 

 

External Announcements: Events

Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies - The Rose(s) that Grew From Concrete: Conversations with Former Gang Members about Violence, Trauma and Policy Options

Date: Thursday October 4th, 2018
Time: 6:00pm to 10:00pm
Location: MacLeod Auditorium, Medical Sciences Building, University of Toronto

The Rose(s) that Grew From Concrete: Conversations with Former Gang Members about Violence, Trauma and Policy Options

The University of Toronto, Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies would like to invite you to a community forum on gangs/gang violence.In recent week’s gang violence in the city
has drawn the attention of law enforcement, politicians and the media/public. While there has been a lot of discussion surrounding the so-called gang problem, there has been inconsistent
and often conflicting knowledge that has informed the issue. The goal of this community forum is to provide an intellectual bridge where former gang members, researchers, policy makers,
law enforcement and state officials are able to discuss and explore the gang phenomena in more detail.

The forum will include:
- firsthand accounts of why youth join gangs and participate in violence,
- new and emergent knowledge/research pertaining to the root causes of gangs/gang violence,
- alternative viewpoints on gangs, including discussions with law enforcement and other community stakeholders and,
- insight into contemporary gang research that may subsequently inform policy making decisions

Panelists will include:
Former Gang Members:

Marcell Wilson (A.V.E. Network)

Jose Vivar (25/7 Fitness/Cross-Over)

& Others

Toronto Police Service:

Gun & Gang Taskforce

Academics:


Adam Ellis, Doctoral Candidate, Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies, University of Toronto, Vanier Scholar, Ex-Gang Member

Professor Scot Wortley, Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies, University of Toronto

Dr. A. Hutchinson, RSW, Associate Professor of Health and Human Services Chair, Department of Health and Human Services, TyndaleU

Dr. Luca Berardi, Assistant Professor, Department of Sociology, McMaster University

(event poster attached)

Registration not required.

Mon, Oct 1: Democracy and Constitutional Reform: Deliberative Versus Populist Constitutionalism (w/ Simone Chambers)

Democracy and Constitutional Reform: Deliberative Versus Populist Constitutionalism

Whereas, populism has sometimes been thought to be a movement that attempts to bypass, discredit, or suspend constitutions, contemporary populism has often progressed and gained ground through embracing and claiming ownership over national constitutions and the “people.” The cases that I look at are Hungary, Poland, Turkey and Venezuela but the threat is quite broad.
Populist constitutionalism poses a problem for scholars and citizens alike who believe that constitutional politics should also be democratic politics. How do we tell the difference between democratically driven constitutionalism and populist constitutionalism? How can citizens participate in constitution-making without hijacking constitutionalism for majoritarian, nationalist, and authoritarian ends?
One of the challenges in identifying normative objections to populist constitutionalism is how to hold on to essential ideas of popular sovereignty and citizen participation without surrendering constitution-making and constitutional limits to the anti-pluralist forces of populism. Deliberative constitutionalism, because it invests popular sovereignty in processes of collective egalitarian discourse rather than in outcomes of majoritarian procedures or an identifiable general will is in a good position to offer a critical yard stick for questioning the democratic credentials (not just liberal) of populist constitutionalism.
In this paper I lay out the main features of populist constitutionalism and then contrast it with three alternatives: liberal constitutionalism, popular constitutionalism, and deliberative constitutionalism. I argue that only deliberative constitutionalism offers a model of constitutional reform that includes citizens but offers practical advice for excluding or mitigating populist forces. The use of referendums in Scotland and Ireland are used as illustrations of deliberate appeals to citizens in constitutional questions.

Simone Chambers
UC Irvine
Political Science

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin 

Tue, Oct 2: The Ethical Crisis in Computing? (Ethics of AI in Context) (w/ Moshe Vardi)

The Ethical Crisis in Computing?

Computer scientists think often of “Ender’s Game” these days. In this award-winning 1985 science-fiction novel by Orson Scott Card, Ender is being trained at Battle School, an institution designed to make young children into military commanders against an unspecified enemy. Ender’s team engages in a series of computer-simulated battles, eventually destroying the enemy’s planet, only to learn then that the battles were very real and a real planet has been destroyed.

Many of us got involved in computing because programming was fun. The benefits of computing seemed intuitive to us. We truly believe that computing yields tremendous societal benefits; for example, the life-saving potential of driverless cars is enormous! Like Ender, however, we realized recently that computing is not a game–it is real–and it brings with it not only societal benefits, but also significant societal costs, such as labor polarization, disinformation, and smart-phone addiction.

The common reaction to this crisis is to label it as an “ethical crisis” and the proposed response is to add courses in ethics to the academic computing curriculum. I will argue that the ethical lens is too narrow. The real issue is how to deal with technology’s impact on society. Technology is driving the future, but who is doing the steering?

☛ please register here

Moshe Vardi
Rice University
Karen Ostrum George Distinguished Service Professor in Computational Engineering
Director, Ken Kennedy Institute for Information Technology

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin 

Wed, Oct 3: What’s Wrong and What’s Right with Deterrence Theories in Criminal Law (w/ Kimmo Nuotio)

What’s Wrong and What’s Right with Deterrence Theories in Criminal Law

Criminal law has many aims, one of them being that it seeks to influence human conduct. Criminal law has in-built theories about human action. Often some sort of rational action theory serves as a model. According to classical law and economics, human beings can be deterred by keeping the costs of offending high enough. The model of rational economic action has famously been challenged by findings of the so-called behavioral economics and law. Human beings simply fail to act rationally when studied empirically. Behavioral law and economics has created its own way, even its own language, to study law and regulation. We all know about ‘endowment’, ‘bounded rationality’, ‘nudging’, and ‘choice architecture’.

The theory of positive general prevention, well known to Continental criminal law scholars, works on somewhat different premises than classical law and economics. According to that theory, human beings are able to internalize the moral and ethical values that the criminal law tells about which in turn gives individuals additional reasons not to offend. This theory could even be linked with the theory of a democratic Rechtsstaat, since the citizens quite obviously have reasons to respect legitimate norms. Even legal doctrines which provide for legal security and predictability could contribute to the legitimacy of criminal law.

We should also mention regulatory theory, which has equally departed from classical law and economics. According to regulatory theory, at least if we read Christopher Hodges, no-blame cultures are most efficient as means to improve the quality of human action, be it in terms of security in civil aviation, or reducing malpractice by medical professionals. Often the solution seems to be to choose another regulatory option than criminal law. For serious violations of interests of others we may still need criminal law. From a regulatory point of view criminal law would still always also interact with ethics and social norms since criminalisations trigger effects on the side of the legal subjects, and on the side of the society at large. Hodges claims that behavioral law and economics is not enough to found socio-legal structures on the reality of how people make decisions. He tries to build an integrated theory, integrating theories of regulation, enforcement, compliance and ethics.

I wish to look at more closely whether behavioral law and economics as well as the theory of regulation call for a reassessment of how we should think about criminal law as a way of regulating behavior. Is behavioral economics still too narrow, too utilitarian, to be relevant for criminal law theory? Isn’t it too reductionist in its style? How would regulatory theory see this? Should we only adopt the psychology part of it?

It seems that the various approaches to and understandings about seeking to influence human behavior have very different criminal policy implications. As concerns environmental criminal law or economic criminal law, to take two examples, the Chicago-style law and economics leads to stressing the severity of (criminal) sanctions, whereas positive general prevention would leave more room for additional ethical reasons for actors in a company frame to work for minimizing the risk of crime. We do not need severe punishments to communicate blame. Much of EU criminal law seems to build on negative general deterrence.

It looks as if it makes sense to stress that criminal law possesses certain specific qualities which go beyond simple instrumental and utilitarian concerns. The theory of positive general prevention might work even if we cannot expect people to act rationally. As criminal law uses blameworthiness to communicate values, this goes well together with the idea that the individuals should be approached as responsible citizens who have the ability to learn to do better. We need to go beyond a utilitarian theory of regulating behavior. This could even be a paradox: we have to introduce non-instrumental views about how criminal law is anchored in the society in order to truly understand how criminal law operates and becomes functional. There is different politics of criminal law involved, and a different view of the society.

Kimmo Nuotio
University of Helsinki
Faculty of Law

12:30 PM - 02:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin 

Wed, Oct 3: Ethics in the City Film Series: Urbanized

☛ please register here

06:00 PM - 08:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
Rm 200, Larkin Building 

Wed, Oct 10: Ethics in the City: Human Cities, Posthuman Cities (w/ Mark Kingwell)

Human Cities, Posthuman Cities

Traditional urban philosophy has focussed on the relationship between humans and their built environments. Thus the emphasis on spaces, forms and circulatory systems as conditioned by the physical features of people. A standard injunction of such philosophy would then be to make cities ‘more human’. But what if the standard human body is no longer the baseline for consciousness within cities? In such a case, cities would have to be reconceived at a basic level.

☛ please register here

Mark Kingwell
University of Toronto
Philosophy

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
Rm 200, Larkin Building 

Mon, Oct 15: Does Nationhood Promote Egalitarian Justice? Challenging the National Identity Argument (w/ Nils Holtug)

Does Nationhood Promote Egalitarian Justice? Challenging the National Identity Argument

According to the national identity argument, a shared national identity is important for two aspects of social cohesion that, in particular, are required for egalitarian, distributive justice, namely trust and solidarity. I critically discuss the national identity argument as it pertains to social justice. I first provide a more detailed account of the argument. Then I consider, in greater detail, different conceptions of the nation on which the national identity argument may rely. Furthermore, I assess two theoretical arguments for why we should expect national identities to promote social cohesion and so distributive justice. According to the first, a shared identity tends to produce the emotional disposition towards compatriots required for trust and solidarity. According to the second, sharing an identity with someone tends to make their behaviour more predictable which makes it easier to trust them. However, neither of these two accounts of the causal mechanism leading from a national identity to trust and solidarity establishes the need for a national identity, or so I argue. For the purpose of assessing the empirical studies that test the national identity argument, I then decompose the argument in terms of the different elements that may be thought to causally impact social cohesion. On this basis, I survey the empirical evidence for and against the national identity argument. One worry pertaining to these studies is that, very often, they do not appropriately distinguish between different conceptions of the nation, or at least do not do so along the lines that political theorists have thought important. Therefore, I go into greater depth with a recent Danish study I have conducted with two colleagues – a study that aims more specifically to test the impact on trust and solidarity of conservative and liberal nationalist identities. I conclude that, just as the theoretical explanations to which nationalists appeal do not sufficiently support the national identity argument, nor does the empirical evidence that has been gathered so far.

☛ please register here

Nils Holtug
University of Copenhagen
Director, Centre for Advanced Migration Studies
Professor of Political Philosophy
Philosophy Section
Department of Media, Cognition and Communication

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin

Tue, Oct 16: Ethics of AI in Context: Accountable AI Systems (w/ Mark Fox)

Accountable AI Systems 

The most recent advances of AI technology, namely neural networks, and their application to sophisticated pattern recognition tasks, such as image classification in automated vehicles, has led to a plethora of concerns regarding accountability, often couched in terms of the capability of these algorithms to explain their decisions. This presentation will address a different type of accountability: system accountability. We will look at the architecture of intelligent systems that are made of large numbers of intelligent agents and explore the issues and possible solutions to accountability when decisions and actions are the result of large numbers of individual decisions made by interacting intelligent agents.

☛ please register here

Mark S. Fox
University of Toronto
Distinguished Professor of Urban Systems Engineering

04:00 PM - 06:00 PM
Centre for Ethics, University of Toronto
200 Larkin 

The Deviant Prison: Eastern State Penitentiary and the Advantage of Difference, 1829-1913

The Deviant Prison: Eastern State Penitentiary and the Advantage of Difference, 1829-1913

Dr. Ashley Rubin, Assistant Professor of Sociology, University of Toronto

Ashley Rubin is an assistant professor of sociology at the University of Toronto. Her research examines criminal punishment from historical, sociological, and sociolegal perspectives and has been published in the Law & Society Review,
Law & Social Inquiry, British Journal of Criminology, Punishment & Society,
and Theoretical Criminology, among other venues. Her central project currently is a book manuscript on Eastern State Penitentiary and its exceptional reliance on the Pennsylvania System of long-term solitary confinement.

Date: Friday Oct. 26 , 2018
Time: 12:30pm to 2:00pm
Location: Ericson Seminar Room (room 265)

A light lunch will be served at 12:00 noon in the Lounge.


The talk will begin at 12:30pm in the Ericson Seminar Room (room 265)
Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies,
14 Queen’s Park Crescent West, Toronto, ON Canada, M5S 3K9


If you are a person with a disability and require accommodation, please contact Lori Wells at 416-978-3722 x226 or email lori.wells@utoronto.ca and we will do our best to make appropriate arrangements.

Hold the Date: Dr. Mark Anthony Geraghty - Friday November 23, 2018 - 12:30pm to 2:00pm

Gacaca, Genocide, Genocide Ideology: The Violent Aftermaths of Transitional Justice in the New Rwanda

Dr. Mark Anthony Geraghty,
Andrew W. Mellon Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Jackman Humanities Institute, University of Toronto

Mark Anthony Geraghty is a socio-cultural anthropologist, ethnographically investigating the violent aftermaths of war and genocide. He received his Ph.D. from the University of Chicago in 2016
and is currently an Andrew W. Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow at the Jackman Humanities Institute, University of Toronto. He is finalizing a book manuscript on the Rwandan state’s on-going campaign
against “genocide ideology” – prohibited in law as “thoughts” of ethnic hatred that threaten the recurrence of genocide. He has conducted over four years of fieldwork in Rwanda, where his research
sites have included prisons, layperson-run genocide courts (Gacaca), military-run “re-education” camps (Ingando), and state-run genocide commemoration events. At the Department of Anthropology
at the University of Toronto, he teaches classes on the topics of: violent aftermaths; language and injury; political anthropology; and ethnographic methods.

Date: Friday November 23, 2018
Time: 12:30 - 2:00pm
Location: Room 265 - Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies, 14 Queen’s Park Crescent West, Toronto, ON Canada, M5S 3K9

A light lunch will be served at 12:00pm in the Lounge

The talk will begin at 12:30pm in the Ericson Seminar Room (room 265)

Centre for Criminology & Sociolegal Studies Speaker Series Fall 2018 Schedule

CrimSL Speaker Series Fall 2018 Schedule

Friday, Oct. 26, 2018
“The Deviant Prison: Eastern State Penitentiary and the Advantage of Difference,1829–1913”
Dr. Ashley Rubin, Assistant Professor of Sociology, University of Toronto

Friday, Nov. 23, 2018
“Gacaca, Genocide, Genocide Ideology: The Violent Aftermaths of Transitional Justice in the New Rwanda”
Dr. Mark Anthony Geraghty, Andrew W. Mellon Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Jackman Humanities Institute, University of Toronto

Thursday, Dec. 6, 2018
“Rights on Trial: How U.S. Workplace Discrimination Law Perpetuates Inequality”
Dr. Ellen Berrey, Assistant Professor of Sociology at the University of Toronto and an affiliated scholar of the American Bar Foundation

Unless otherwise specified, talks are held in CrimSL’s Ericson Seminar Room, room 265 at 14 Queen’s Park Crescent West.

A light lunch will be served at 12:00 noon in the CrimSL lounge


If you are a person with a disability and require accommodation, please contact Lori Wells at 416-978-3722 x226 or email lori.wells@utoronto.ca and we will do our best to make appropriate arrangements.

External Announcements: Opportunities

Osler Diversity Scholarship

https://www.osler.com/en/applications/osler-diversity-scholarship

 

Hi everyone!

 

Whether you’re on campus or abroad, I hope you’ve all settled back into your final year of law school. As you can imagine, it has been a busy time here and we’re so grateful for the candidate input you have been providing thus far.  But we miss you!!

 

I’m excited to share information about Osler’s new Diversity Scholarship, a program focused on recognizing law student diversity leaders who are making a difference in either their school, the legal profession or the greater community. The scholarship is focused on incoming second-year law students attending a Canadian law school. Osler will be awarding up to two $2,500 scholarships in early 2019.  To find out more about the program, please visit https://www.osler.com/en/applications/osler-diversity-scholarship.

 

I’m hoping you’ll help to share this award information with the second-year students at your school. Our goal is to ensure that all students are aware of the scholarship and have the opportunity to apply.

 

Thank you for your assistance with spreading the word. Please feel free to reach out with any questions and please don’t be a stranger – would love to hear from you!

 

Christina

 


Christina Beaudoin
Director, Student Programs and Legal Recruitment

416.862.6527 | cbeaudoin@osler.com
Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP | osler.com

Start right. oslerstudents.com

 

 

The William Tetley Award 2019

The Award: The Canadian Maritime Law Association ("CMLA") has established a literary prize, to be called "Professor William Tetley Award" (the "Award").

Purpose: The Honorable William Tetley, CM, QC, President of the Faculty of Law, McGill University, Montreal, for some thirty-five years, in recognition of his outstanding contribution to development of maritime law and maritime law education, both in Canada and around the world.

Nature: The Award will take the form of a monetary prize of between $ 500.00 and $ 1,000.00, to be awarded by Canadian authors of high-quality articles, papers or publications.

Topics: Submissions need not be confined to topics of maritime law, but may be devoted to any subject of an educational nature relevant to the marine industry.

Publication: Winning submissions will be published in the Canadian Maritime Law Association Journal (or republished there with the consent of the copyright holder if already published elsewhere).

Frequency: The Award will not necessarily be issued every year, but only to be awarded by the selection committee of the United States.

Submissions: Submissions (in English or French) may be made by the authors themselves or by anyone acting on their behalf. Submissions should be printed on 8-1 / 2 "x 11" paper, accompanied by an electronic copy on a CD-ROM in pdf format, and sent to:

Mr. P. Jeremy Bolger, 
Chair of the Selection Committee 
Professor William Tetley Award 
c / o Borden Ladner Gervais LLP 
1000 De La Gauchetière West Street, Suite 900 
Montreal, Quebec H3B 5H4.

Submissions must include the name, postal and email addresses and phone number (s) of the author and the submitter (if other than the author). 

Submissions can be made at any time and will be evaluated by the selection committee. The committee will notify the author and submitter of its decision within a reasonable time following receipt of submissions.

For more information, please visit: http://www.cmla.org/tetleyaward.php

J. Stephen Tatrallyay Memorial Award

The Canadian College of Construction Lawyers has established and administers the J. Stephen Tatrallyay Memorial Prize ($1000) given in respect of academic student publishable papers on any current issue of interest to construction law practitioners and topical to the practice of construction law in Canada. The criteria for award of the prize are described in the attached information sheet. The College will select the successful paper in its discretion. Students who have submitted a paper but do not win the monetary prize may still be offered the opportunity to have their paper published in this Journal. 

The IHRP's Petra Molnar co-authors "Ottawa’s use of AI in immigration system has profound implications for human rights"

Friday, September 28, 2018

In a commentary in the Globe and Mail, International Human Rights Program researcher Petra Molnar (JD 2016) and Ronald Deibert, Director of the Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto, warn about the implications of the federal government's use of artificial intelligence in refugee cases ("Ottawa’s use of AI in immigration system has profound implications for human rights," September 26, 2018).

$30 million campaign for students launched at Faculty of Law

Friday, September 28, 2018

The Campaign for #ExcellencewithoutBarriers is the largest bursary campaign at any Canadian law school, to help increase access to law school for the best and brightest students, no matter their financial means

By Lucianna Ciccocioppo / Dhoui Chang

Prof. Anita Anand writes "Ford government decision is a step backward for investor protection"

Wednesday, September 26, 2018

In a commentary in the Globe and Mail, Prof. Anita Anand expresses concerns about the decision of the new Government of Ontario to oppose a reform proposed by the Ontario Securities Commission intended to improve investor protection ("Ford government decision is a step backward for investor protection," September 25, 2018).

Read the full commentary on the Globe and Mail website, or below.

Pages