Instructor(s): Kerry Wilkins
Pre-requisites/Co-requisites
Indigenous Peoples and Canadian Law (LAW108) or Indigenous Peoples and the Constitution of Canada (LAW370)

Note: This is an eligible course for credit towards the Aboriginal Legal Studies Certificate.

Note: Students who do not meet the pre-/co-requisite may enroll with the instructor's permission.

This course is an exercise in legal archaeology. Students will study in depth, from beginning to end, a significant current or recent Canadian case that deals with Aboriginal law. This year, we’ll revisit Dickson v. Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation, a case from Yukon currently under reserve at the Supreme Court of Canada. It’s about whether, and if so how, the Charter of Rights applies to an Indigenous community exercising a right of self-government pursuant to a modern treaty. The class will read, and meet weekly throughout the term to discuss, in sequence, relevant provisions of the Vuntut Gwitchin Final Agreement and self-government agreement, the Vuntut Gwitchin Constitution, the statutory provisions governing conduct of this proceeding, the written arguments and decisions in the lower courts, the written arguments (on the leave application and on the merits) at the Supreme Court of Canada, and (if it’s released before winter term ends) the S.C.C. decision itself. We'll also watch (on video) and discuss the oral hearing before the S.C.C.. There may also be opportunities for students to argue the case orally in class and to meet and discuss it with the principal counsel who argued it.

Evaluation
Students' grades will reflect class participation (10%) and written work (90%). Each student will write a case comment, a factum or a judgment in the case of approximately 20 pages (5,000 words). JD students have the additional option of writing, for one additional ungraded credit, a longer paper that meets the usual requirements for a supervised upper-year research paper (SUYRP), if they: (1) obtain the prior approval of the assistant dean; and (2) obtain the consent of a full-time faculty member to co-supervise the SUYRP with the instructor. In past years, SUYRPs completed in this course have qualified as major papers toward the Certificate in Aboriginal Legal Studies.
Academic year
2023 - 2024

At a Glance

Second Term
Credits
2
Hours
2
SUYRP

Enrolment

Maximum
8

6 JD
2 LLM/SJD/MSL/SJD U

Schedule

W: 4:10 - 6:00 pm